Letters from Sing Sing · NBC News Studios

Integrity

March 13, 2023·45 min·2 clips

JJ says the prosecutors asked about his friends, his phone call with Maria, and even Dan's legal fees.

In October 2012, the episode returns to Sing Sing. The narrator meets JJ in his housing block, standing on the second tier outside his cell, where a shared television still carries the weight of the investigation that aired eight months earlier. JJ has already seen the broadcast there. He says it brought a mix of happiness, sadness, confusion, and a purging feeling, but the deeper reaction was hope because strangers across the country, including junior high school kids, wrote to say they believed him. That support means something to him. For the first time, he feels less alone and less like an underdog. It gives him a sense that people are finally hearing him, even though he remains frustrated that the attention has not yet brought freedom. He expected action. Instead, the episode settles into the painful gap between public attention and institutional response, showing how a story can expose a wrong without fixing it right away. The conversation then turns to the women tied to the case. They describe feeling uneasy after an interview with the conviction integrity unit, especially because the process felt less like a search for truth than a chance to discredit them. That distrust changes the strategy. Bob suggests they get their own lawyer, and a few weeks later he connects them with Ron Kuby, who takes the matter pro bono after hearing how the unit handled them. Ron does not sound impressed. He says he had hoped a conviction integrity unit would work openly and aggressively, but instead he sees a system that is not open, not transparent, and fully adversarial. The episode keeps pressing on that point. Near the end, the narrator comes home to a large yellow envelope. Inside are the police reports from JJ's case, a reminder that information can be held back while a person remains behind bars. The final note lands hard. JJ says he has spent half his life in prison because people keep holding back information and keeping the wrong story alive.

As heard by us

A careful wrongful-conviction story about hope, delay, and the records that keep the case moving.

This episode tracks a man who remains inside Sing Sing after NBC aired an investigation into his case, and the real force comes from the delay between renewed hope and the slow machinery of post-conviction review.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a wrongful-conviction story that sits with the waiting, not just the verdict.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Letters from Sing Sing