Leadoff Talk: A Baseball Podcast With Katelin and Gabe · Leadoff Talk: A Baseball Podcast

Episode 40: Winners and Losers of the Off-Season (Spring Training is HERE!!)

·37 min·2 clips

Carlos Correa's offseason was a disaster: three teams, three failed signings, each losing him millions.

Katelin and Gabe, hosts of the baseball podcast Leadoff Talk, analyze the winners and losers of the MLB offseason as spring training begins. They frame the discussion around which teams improved or declined through free agency and trades. The hosts immediately identify the Philadelphia Phillies as a major winner for signing Trea Turner and securing a full season from Brandon Marsh. Gabe argues the Phillies' shortstop upgrade from Didi Gregorius to Turner is significant, and the pitching staff returns intact. Katelin points to a specific defensive adjustment for Nick Castellanos that improved his fielding, referencing a key catch in Game 1 of the World Series. They agree Carlos Correa is the offseason's biggest loser after his deals with the Giants and Mets fell through due to physical concerns, forcing him back to Minnesota on a reduced contract. The hosts criticize the Chicago White Sox for losing José Abreu and only adding Andrew Benintendi and the troubled Mike Clevinger. They label the San Francisco Giants a loser for missing out on both Aaron Judge and Carlos Correa, settling for players like Mitch Haniger. Katelin calls the Toronto Blue Jays' offseason "weird" for trading Teoscar Hernández and top prospect Gabriel Moreno for Daulton Varsho and reliever Erik Swanson. The St. Louis Cardinals earn praise for addressing their catcher need by signing Willson Contreras after Yadier Molina's retirement. The hosts commend their hometown Cleveland Guardians for adding Josh Bell and Mike Zunino while celebrating the departure of Owen Miller. A surprising insight is that the Pittsburgh Pirates, while not contenders, had an underrated offseason by adding veterans like Andrew McCutchen and Carlos Santana to mentor young players. Katelin finds it hilarious that the contact-focused Guardians signed Mike Zunino, a player in the first percentile for strikeouts. They debate whether the Blue Jays' trade for Erik Swanson could become a rare win-win deal if he stabilizes their bullpen. The hosts note the New York Mets spent around $600 million, replacing Jacob deGrom with Justin Verlander. The tone is casual and conversational, filled with inside jokes and personal anecdotes, like Gabe sharing a high school connection to Chris Bassitt. They frequently reference specific social media videos and trade value calculators to support their opinions. This episode is perfect for fans who enjoy detailed, team-by-team offseason analysis with a strong, opinionated perspective from hosts who follow the game daily. Listeners who prefer structured analysis or are sensitive to strong language and casual digressions might want to skip it.

As heard by us

A grounded offseason read that likes the Phillies, takes the Pirates seriously, and still cannot quite settle the Blue Jays.

This episode keeps the MLB offseason in a clear, grounded frame. The Phillies come out looking smart: Trea Turner lengthens the lineup, Brandon Marsh gets a full season in center, and the defense should settle if Turner holds short.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a quick offseason scoreboard while spring training starts to take over?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Leadoff Talk: A Baseball Podcast With Katelin and Gabe