Leadoff Talk: A Baseball Podcast With Katelin and Gabe · Leadoff Talk: A Baseball Podcast

Episode 40: Winners and Losers of the Off-Season (Spring Training is HERE!!)

·37 min·2 clips
Carlos Correa's offseason was a disaster: three teams, three failed signings, each losing him millions.
Spring training is here and the team finally gets back on record after a long offseason. Gabe and Caitlin first catch up on the Hall of Fame talk they missed, including Scott Rowland getting in, Todd Helton and Billy Wagner being left out, and Fred McGriff’s Legends Committee route. Then they move into a winners and losers pass over the MLB offseason. The Phillies get the clearest approval. Adding Turner to the offense helps, putting him at shortstop helps defensively, and a full season of Brandon Marsh in center is part of why the move feels clean. The Pirates get a more practical nod. Carlos Santana, Rich Hill, and Austin Hedges are not glamorous additions, but the case is that they can keep the team around .500, stay competitive, and maybe turn those bets into deadline pieces later. That makes sense to them because it treats the deadline as a tool instead of a panic button. Toronto is the team that makes them hesitate. The Blue Jays traded Teoscar Hernandez and their top catching prospect, then brought in Varshow, Kiermaier, and Chris Bassett. There is real value in that package, especially on defense, but they keep coming back to how much Toronto gave up to make it happen. The offseason feels odd because the team made major changes while also carrying the memory of last year’s heavy pitching spending, which did not fully pay off. Jose Barrios is the example they keep circling back to when they talk about that risk. The segment keeps testing the same question from different angles: who actually improved, who just reshaped the problem, and who spent a lot to create more uncertainty. The answers are practical rather than dramatic, but they are pretty clear once the tradeoffs are laid out.

As heard by us

A grounded offseason read that likes the Phillies, takes the Pirates seriously, and still cannot quite settle the Blue Jays.

This episode keeps the MLB offseason in a clear, grounded frame. The Phillies come out looking smart: Trea Turner lengthens the lineup, Brandon Marsh gets a full season in center, and the defense should settle if Turner holds short.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Need a quick offseason scoreboard while spring training starts to take over?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on