KunstlerCast - Conversations: Converging Catastrophes of the 21st Century

KunstlerCast 431 — Thomas Fowler on the Diminishing Returns of Artificial Intelligence

·1 hr 3 min·5 clips

Thomas Fowler argues AI is just one piece of our society's fragile over-reliance on excessive investments in complexity.

The episode features a conversation between host James Howard Kunstler and guest Thomas Fowler, an expert in systems analysis and author of a book on AI. Fowler begins by framing AI as part of a broader societal problem of over-investment in complexity, making systems vulnerable to failure. He shares a personal anecdote about a blackout in Spain that highlighted how technology creates single points of failure. Fowler then debunks common AI fantasies, comparing them to historical alchemy and noting that most AI labeling is marketing hype. He explains that generative AI chatbots are the only truly new development, while pattern recognition has existed for decades. The discussion turns to AI's impact on education, with Fowler noting how AI-written essays undermine learning and critical thinking. Fowler delves into AI's philosophical underpinnings, arguing it is based on David Hume's epistemology, which cannot handle abstract entities like imaginary numbers or symphonies. He illustrates this with examples from mathematics and history. The conversation covers economic aspects, with Fowler citing reports that AI investments may not yield returns due to lack of demand and high energy costs. He also mentions regulatory possibilities as public backlash grows. Fowler highlights lesser-known issues like AI training data being poisoned by AI-generated content and the self-limiting nature of technology, such as chip miniaturization hitting atomic limits. The episode concludes with reflections on AI's inability to replicate human creativity and sentience, and the dangers of confusing virtual experiences with reality. Fowler warns of potential market failures and financial losses from overinvestment in AI.

As heard by us

A skeptical AI conversation finds its strongest case in the everyday misery of a refused payment card.

Artificial intelligence gets a skeptical systems check in this conversation with Thomas B. Fowler, whose new book takes up the technology's foundations, limits, benefits, and risks.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play when AI promises sound grand and your patience for technology's password-and-button maze is already running low.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from KunstlerCast - Conversations: Converging Catastrophes of the 21st Century