Kids First Podcast - A Charter School Podcast with Chris Neeley · Kids First Podcast

Jonathan Butcher of the Heritage Foundation

·34 min·3 clips

Jonathan Butcher exposes how DEI trainings fail to change behavior and often leave participants more angry.

This episode features Jonathan Butcher, the Will Skillman Fellow in Education at the Heritage Foundation, discussing charter schools and education policy with host Chris Neeley. Butcher brings expertise from his roles at the Goldwater Institute, the Beacon Center of Tennessee, and the South Carolina Public Charter School District board. The conversation centers on the principles and practical impacts of school choice, drawing from Butcher's research and firsthand experience. Butcher recounts helping launch the South Carolina Public Charter School District around 2009-2010, assisting new schools with operations like enrollment systems and standardized testing. He emphasizes the essential trade-off where charter schools gain autonomy over hiring, curriculum, and daily operations in exchange for strict academic and financial accountability from their authorizers. The host shares personal examples, noting his three children attend different school types, including a private school and a charter school serving his son with Down syndrome. Butcher cites specific innovative models, including BASIS college-prep schools in Arizona, the Leona Group for alternative education, and a Florida tutoring center funded by education savings accounts. A notable insight is Butcher's claim that charter schools, on average, serve a higher percentage of disadvantaged and minority students than traditional public schools. He references a proposal for an "EdCoin" system, where per-pupil funding would be attached to individual students for use at any school. Butcher points to recent state-level policies, like Iowa's newly approved universal private school choice program and West Virginia's legislation explicitly supporting micro-schools and learning pods. He argues that Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) training programs are ineffective, citing research from the journal *Anthropology Today* suggesting they can increase bitterness and fail to change behavior. Butcher contends DEI concepts originate from the same neo-Marxist critical theory as critical race theory, which he opposes. The host states his charter district discontinued its DEI program and now reports a diverse student body: 49% in poverty, 47% students of color, and 17% with disabilities. Butcher concludes that the fundamental reason for supporting charter schools is that every child has different needs and deserves a quality educational option tailored to them. The tone is conversational and advocacy-oriented, blending personal anecdotes with policy analysis and examples from various states. This episode would strongly appeal to listeners interested in conservative education policy, school choice expansion, and charter school operations. Those seeking a critical perspective on charter schools or alternative views on DEI and curriculum debates might find it less engaging.

As heard by us

A focused school-choice conversation that leans practical and stays close to the charter-school debate.

Jonathan Butcher keeps the discussion anchored in education policy and school choice, with a clear focus on how flexibility can serve families and students.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Jonathan Butcher's case for charter-school flexibility, from a Heritage Foundation education-policy voice.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Kids First Podcast - A Charter School Podcast with Chris Neeley