Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast · Melissa Morgan, Bleav

LOOKS LIKE THE DEALINE IS HERE: NANCY GUTHRIE

·1 hr 3 min·4 clips

At 9:48 PM, a smart garage door and a doorbell camera place Nancy Guthrie at the house, then the timeline turns.

1. Just The Tipsters covers the missing-person case of Nancy Guthrie, the 84-year-old mother of Savannah Guthrie in Tucson, Arizona. 2. Hosts Melissa Morgan and Joshua Bevan drive the story, with Melissa leading the case recap and Joshua reacting to the details in real time. 3. The episode asks what happened to Nancy Guthrie between her dinner at Annie's house and the first signs of trouble after midnight. 4. Nancy took an Uber at 5:32 PM on Saturday, January 31, to her daughter Annie's home about four miles away. 5. The family ate dinner and played Mahjong at 9:48 PM, and the garage door opened at 9:50 PM before the timeline went quiet. 6. A doorbell camera disconnected at 1:47 AM on Sunday, February 1, and software detected a person at 2:12 AM. 7. Melissa says investigators believed someone was in the home for 41 minutes, from 1:47 to 2:28 AM. 8. Nancy's phone, purse, keys, car, and watch were still in the house, while her watch had been on the charger. 9. Annie arrived at 11:56 AM, police were called at 12:03 PM, and officers reached the home at 12:15 PM. 10. Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos later said the home had become a crime scene and asked neighbors to review their video footage. 11. Melissa compares the case response to the Idaho Four investigation and argues that local agencies need better public information officers. 12. She says she took a 2023 class called "managing the media for law enforcement," where most classmates were from small departments. 13. The episode notes that many departments train one deputy or officer to serve as a PIO, while larger agencies hire retired or former journalists. 14. A Tuesday visit from NewsNation's Brian Entin led to blood on the front porch, which he filmed after arriving to the house. 15. Melissa says the blood was a few drops rather than a splatter pattern, and it later came back as Nancy's blood. 16. A ransom note then arrived at KGUN and KOLD, and the same note later reached TMZ with a Bitcoin demand and two deadlines. 17. Melissa calls Bitcoin a modern offshore account and links it to ransomware, crypto wallets, and money that is difficult to trace. 18. Savannah Guthrie, Cameron Guthrie, and Annie Guthrie appear in family statements that ask for direct contact and proof of life. 19. The episode is conversational, heavily reactive, and built around Melissa's case analysis rather than formal narration. 20. Listeners who like true-crime timeline breakdowns with media strategy will get the most from it, while people wanting a concise solved-case recap may skip it.

As heard by us

A missing-person case moves from loose banter to real concern, with a grounded tone that keeps the case feeling immediate.

Just the Tipsters starts in teasing, flirting, and a lingering cold, then settles into the disappearance of an 84-year-old woman. The important details land cleanly: Nancy's car, keys, purse, phone, and watch are still there, and the sheriff's department treats the situation as…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A missing woman, a police search that turns urgent fast, and hosts who keep it loose until the facts get grim.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast