Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast · Melissa Morgan, Bleav

LOOKS LIKE SEBASTIAN ROGERS NEEDS TO BE FOUND

·54 min·3 clips

Sebastian left his phone, shoes, and jacket behind before he vanished from his bedroom.

1. Just The Tipsters: True Crime Podcast ties Sebastian Rogers’ disappearance to a broader discussion of missing-person cases and law-enforcement response. 2. Host Melissa Morgan and co-host Joshua Pizza Beans Bevan frame the episode, and Melissa uses her research and commentary to connect the cases. 3. The episode asks why 15-year-old Sebastian Rogers vanished from Hendersonville, Tennessee, after what his mother describes as a normal day. 4. Melissa says Sebastian and his mother went shopping, ate dinner, played video games at an arcade, and watched television before bed. 5. Katie heard a thud around 10 p.m., asked Sebastian if he was okay, and he replied, “yeah, I’m fine.” 6. By morning, Sebastian’s phone, shoes, and jacket were still at home, which Melissa treats as a major detail in the case. 7. Melissa notes that Sebastian was autistic and had sensory issues, including sensitivity to rough ground and dislike of being barefoot. 8. She says Sebastian was small for his age, about 5'5" and 120 pounds, wore glasses, and now would be 17. 9. Melissa says the initial search lasted eight days and used ground teams, planes, and drones before the case moved from search mode to investigation status. 10. She says Sebastian’s father, Seth Rogers, has searched in Ohio, Virginia, Kentucky, and Mississippi. 11. Melissa highlights the public pressure on the Sumner County Sheriff’s Office, including Seth Rogers’ protest outside the department on the case anniversary. 12. Seth Rogers says local law enforcement should “put your ego aside” and let the FBI take over. 13. Melissa also discusses the Nancy Guthrie case update, where the Pima County Sheriff says DNA from the house is complicated because it is commingled. 14. She explains the family’s reward increase to $1 million and says the FBI reward in that case had been built up in stages. 15. Melissa describes FBI activity at Nancy Guthrie’s house, including work in the garage, guest house, and outside areas. 16. She says investigators are also debating porch-camera stills, including a backpack that appears in some frames and disappears in others. 17. The episode has a conversational, argumentative tone, with Melissa and Joshua interrupting each other and testing theories in real time. 18. The pacing moves between case reporting, family reaction, and side commentary about rewards, DNA, and camera footage. 19. People following missing-person cases and law-enforcement updates would likely want this episode. 20. Listeners wanting a tightly focused forensic breakdown may skip the banter.

As heard by us

A loose, talky missing-person episode that eventually locks onto the urgency of the case and the tip line.

Just the Tip-Sters treats a missing-person case as a loose, conversational discussion that starts with playful banter before turning toward the urgency of a case that still needs tips and answers.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want a true-crime episode that opens with playful host banter and settles into a missing-person case with real urgency underneath.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast