Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast · Melissa Morgan, Bleav

LOOKS LIKE BILL AND PEGGY STEPHENSON NEED JUSTICE

·1 hr·3 clips

Detective Coy Cox says, "we never found a murder scene. We found a staged scene."

1. Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast covers the Bill and Peggy Stevenson case from northern Kentucky. 2. Melissa from Just the Tipsters joins Jen and Cam, and Detective Coy Cox matters because he has worked the case for years. 3. The episode asks what kind of person or people would kill Bill and Peggy Stevenson and stage the condo scene. 4. Melissa says the FBI called the case a "one percenter," meaning it was unusually bizarre and rare. 5. Bill and Peggy were 74 years old, married about 53 years, and had three children and several grandchildren. 6. Peggy played the organ at church, and Bill served as a deacon and ran a truck-stop ministry south of Cincinnati. 7. The couple missed church on Sunday morning after a family member checked on them and found both had been murdered. 8. Coy Cox said, "we never found a murder scene. We found a staged scene," and Melissa describes bodies moved from room to room. 9. The condo had garbage dumped on parts of the scene, and furniture and personal items were turned upside down. 10. Bill’s $200 money clip and Peggy’s jewelry armoire were left behind, which points away from robbery. 11. The estimated death window is between 1 a.m. and 4 a.m., and Melissa says a medical device helped narrow that timing. 12. Cox believed the day of the week mattered because the killer may have wanted the couple found on Sunday, not because of Memorial Day itself. 13. Melissa says a trucker was seen pounding on the ministry door days earlier, and a later tip led investigators to a man living off the grid in California. 14. The case includes mixed DNA from two males and one female, and Melissa says the profile is not yet fully separable. 15. The team has also worked with the VDoc Society, Othram Labs, psychics, and behavioral analysts from the Boone County Sheriff’s Department. 16. Melissa says there was no sexual assault, no robbery, and no clear burglary motive that fits the amount of planning at the condo. 17. The conversation sounds like two true-crime fans comparing notes while Melissa keeps returning to Cox’s phrase about the case needing one more brick. 18. The format is conversational and investigative, with family history, suspect leads, and technical details about DNA and scene staging. 19. Listeners who like unsolved homicide analysis and police process will want this. 20. Listeners wanting a neat answer or light banter should skip this.

As heard by us

A close case with real tension, plain-spoken hosts, and just enough mess to stay gripping.

This episode stays close to the pain of the Bill and Peggy Stephenson case, and that is what gives it weight. The hosts sound like they want the facts handled carefully, not padded out.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a case that feels one step from cracked open.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast