Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast · Melissa Morgan, Bleav

FEELS LIKE YOU CAN'T BLAME THE MOON: THE SMITH FAMILY MASSACRE

·50 min·10 clips

Just The Tipsters opens with a familiar pile of chatter. Melissa Morgan and Joshua Winebottle Bevan trade jokes about bikini bars, hairnets, and whether the show should become a morning zoo program. The banter is intentionally silly, but it also makes the room feel real before the case turns serious. The hosts thank a new Patreon supporter and talk through a minor platform glitch. That housekeeping keeps the episode loose and lived-in. Once the case takes over, the tone tightens. The story moves to Donald's house, which is not far, maybe a mile away, and is smaller than the others around it. Donald lives there alone, has a bunch of dogs apparently, and remains close to his family. That ordinary setting makes the case feel even uglier. The hosts spend time on interview footage of Donald. They pay close attention to the way he answers questions by repeating them back. When told that the rest of his family is dead, he responds with a flat calm that feels rehearsed. The detectives keep pressing, and the contrast is part of the point. One younger detective comes off almost aw-shucks while still trying to hold the line. An older detective reads as the sharper presence in the room. The hosts treat that dynamic as its own kind of evidence. They also sit with the strangeness of a man who says he will show emotion when the moment is right. The episode never gets slick or institutional. It stays conversational, blunt, and angry in the way this case wants.

As heard by us

Messy and unsettling, it sharpens once the interviews start speaking for themselves.

A family murder case gets the Just The Tipsters treatment: loose banter first, then a sharp turn into interview footage and the eerie calm of Donald repeating that his whole family is dead.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a weirdly calm murder interrogation with banter before the blow

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Just The Tip-Sters: True Crime Podcast