James O'Brien's Mystery Hour · Global

Some smells are better than others

·47 min·4 clips
A physics teacher reveals why your drill loses power over long extension leads using a corridor analogy.
Mystery Hour runs on questions. James O'Brien opens by saying this is the weekly chance to get the kind of satisfaction you do not usually find anywhere else on the radio dial, and that even listeners new to the format will enjoy it. He gives the same number, 03456060973, to people with mysteries and to people with answers. The board game is the prize for a favourite contribution, and he notes that you can also buy your own by going to mysteryhour.co.uk, because the management's decision is final. Kira begins with the first puzzle. She says she quite likes the smell of petrol and bitumen, remembers the fence oil on the garage fence at home, and admits she used to lick coal as a child because she loved the smell of that. James takes that in and suggests she probably had an iron deficiency or something like that, which keeps things in the same odd, practical register. The smell question stays in play. When Kira asks why some smells are liked and others are not, he hears the shape of a wider mystery and quickly warns listeners that they are not here to turn it into the missing word game. He says so outright. The small correction matters because it keeps the format honest while still letting the joke breathe. Words start to matter too. James says extraordinary is probably the word he overuses most, puts discombobulated near the top, and says serendipity is a beautiful word whose place in the rotation changes with the seasons. Then the drill arrives. A caller from Gillingham in Dorset has been mending a fence in the garden after the winds brought it down, and because his cordless drill is broken he is using an electric drill with a cable trailing all the way down the garden. He notices that the drill is not quite as powerful over about 40 yards as when it is plugged straight into the mains, and James keeps prodding the setup as the question builds. The show closes briskly. James points listeners to Catch Up on Global Player and James O'Brien Daily before handing over to Sheila Fogarty.

As heard by us

A smell puzzle and a drill problem give ordinary curiosity a brisk, self-aware airing.

James O'Brien's Mystery Hour settles into the familiar rhythm of questions and answers, with the host underlining that the exchange itself is where the charm sits.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a smell question and a 40-yard drill cable in the same hour.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on