James O'Brien's Mystery Hour · Global

I haven't got the physics

·48 min·4 clips
An engineer reveals why harnessing deep-sea pressure for energy is possible but economically unfeasible.
James O'Brien begins by setting Mystery Hour apart from the rest of the programme. He presents it as a weekly slot built on small mysteries and the satisfaction of hearing them settled. The feature is framed almost like a game, with a board-game prize for the contributor he likes best. A caller raises the question of whether bones have calorific content. The discussion moves between instinct, science, and a bit of mock-serious sorting. O'Brien keeps pushing at the premise, asking how anyone would test it properly and whether the bone itself matters once the meat is removed. The exchange is playful, but it is not sloppy. The show keeps circling back to what counts as a sensible question, which is part of its charm. Another line of thought wanders into the idea of big-boned chickens, which O'Brien uses to show how awkward it can be to generalise from one animal to another. Graham from Banbury then supplies an answer to the steam question. He explains that steam is actually invisible gas. What people think of as steam is often condensed water, visible as tiny droplets. O'Brien presses that explanation a little further. He asks what changes when the water is boiling hard and what happens when it comes off the heat. Graham answers by separating the invisible vapour from the visible droplets that form as the steam cools. The conversation becomes a neat little lesson without losing its radio looseness. O'Brien reacts in real time, checking qualifications and teasing the fact that a degree and PhD in physics and engineering have finally found an outlet. The joke lands as affectionate rather than dismissive. The hour keeps the same shape throughout. A caller puts something odd on the table. O'Brien tests it, doubts it, and lets it stand only when it has earned its place. The answers are allowed to be exact, but the tone stays conversational. That balance is what makes Mystery Hour move. It can drift from calories to condensation without sounding awkward, because the real subject is not the science alone but the human urge to ask. O'Brien treats that urge with sceptical warmth. He also keeps reminding listeners that the pleasure is communal. Someone rings in with a question, someone else rings in with an answer, and the result is a live chain of curiosity. The format depends on people being willing to look slightly ridiculous before being proved right. Even when the subject turns technical, the language stays approachable. The show does not flatten the questions into dry instruction. It keeps the small comic tension between ordinary language and exact science. The steam explanation is especially strong because it corrects a common assumption without turning smug. It names the visible mist, then separates it from the vapour above the water. The result is clear, tidy, and satisfying. The calorie question has a different energy. It is messier, more speculative, and slightly daft in the best way. O'Brien lets that uncertainty breathe long enough for the joke to land. The episode also reinforces the show's basic promise. Not every question is huge, but each one is treated as worthy of proper attention. That makes the whole thing feel democratic in a very radio way. O'Brien's role is half host, half referee. He steadies the game without smoothing out the rough edges. The interruptions, hesitations, and quick corrections are part of the appeal. The result is a conversation that feels live, mildly chaotic, and good-naturedly exacting. It rewards listeners who enjoy a host thinking aloud with the audience rather than above it. The best moments arrive when a funny premise unexpectedly turns into a real explanation. By the end, Mystery Hour has done what it always aims to do. It has made curiosity feel social, funny, and just serious enough. The title promise of satisfaction turns out to be real, if slightly ridiculous. The hour leaves you with the sense that odd questions deserve better treatment than they usually get. James O'Brien gives them that treatment, and he does it with a raised eyebrow.

As heard by us

A dry call-in puzzle show that treats small questions with real care.

James O'Brien's Mystery Hour is at its best when it takes a small question and refuses to treat it as small. Here, the conversation starts with bones and calories, then turns into a plain but satisfying explanation of why steam can look solid even when it is not.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want steam, bones, and brisk British curiosity with a proper payoff.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on