It Could Happen Here · Cool Zone Media and iHeartPodcasts

How to Break a Union From the Inside: The NFL Players Association, Pt. 1

April 6, 2026·39 min·2 clips

Tom Brady and Drew Brees helped kill the rookie wage and accidentally destroyed the NFL's middle class.

The cleanest evidence is almost too dumb to need explaining. In the 2010 uncapped season, Jerry Jones and Dan Snyder spend the way owners spend when the formal limit goes away. Then the other owners punish them. The host and guest treat that fine as a giant blinking sign over the NFL's basic contradiction: teams are supposed to compete, but ownership can still move as one bloc against players. The joke works because the facts sound worse when said plainly. If the teams are separate competitors, fining owners for paying people looks less like discipline and more like open collusion. Madden becomes the easy model. Turn off the salary cap, spend freely, then watch the billionaire class come down on anyone who breaks the shared restraint. The monopoly problem is sitting right there. In the hosts' telling, the union helps the league work around that problem, because the NFL can point to collective bargaining while keeping huge owner control. CBA gets translated without ceremony. A collective bargaining agreement is not treated as boring paperwork here. It is where power gets written down. The hosts keep widening the frame. A quick comparison to the NBA, Kawhi Leonard, and Steve Ballmer makes the same point: other billionaires have reasons to keep people from digging through their arrangements. Nobody sounds shocked for long. The mood is tired because the pattern is familiar. Management fights management when someone risks disturbing the anti-player consensus. Charles McDonald's work comes up near the close. By the end, the episode sets up part two with the claim that there seems to be good evidence of the NFL paying someone specifically to keep control of the union. That is the darker turn. The story is not just that owners bargain hard. It is that a union can be weakened while still appearing to represent labor. The closing advice is blunt: if a union fails its members, build better ones.

As heard by us

A pointed look at NFL ownership power, union leverage, and the labor fight around the 2011 CBA.

It Could Happen Here uses the NFL Players Association story to look at how much power NFL owners can exercise when labor costs and bargaining leverage are on the line.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get the NFL's union-control playbook, not a scoreboard recap.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from It Could Happen Here