Is It Saturday Yet? A College Football Podcast · Student Union Sports

College Football Playoff Round 2 Picks & Predictions

·1 hr 1 min·5 clips
Why did the first round of the College Football Playoff spark such intense online outrage among fans?
Luke Owens opens with the show’s familiar question and then brings in Bryce Hopwood and Andrew Diaz. The panel is irritated right away. They spend the early stretch on the first round of the College Football Playoff and the reaction it drew online. Nobody tries to pretend every game was good. They say some were bad. They also refuse to let that wipe out the bigger argument. SMU still gets defended. Tennessee still gets defended, even after getting blown out by Ohio State. The panel keeps coming back to the idea that the system can be improved without tossing out the teams that earned their spots. Cade Klubnik gets a quick shoutout for leading all passers and passing yards, which at least kept the weekend from feeling completely dead. From there, the show moves into Penn State and Boise State. The conversation gets more specific. The neutral site matters. Indoors matters. Penn State’s defense matters a lot. Abdul Carter is treated like a menace Boise State will have to survive, and the secondary comes up as another wall to climb. Dom DeLuca gets a name-drop after making two picks, one of them going for six. Boise State also gets some respect. The panel says Boise is a touch better than SMU and notes that a neutral indoor game may suit them better than a trip into Happy Valley. Then the discussion narrows to the real pressure point. If Boise State is going to hang around, Maddox Madston probably has to throw the ball. The hosts circle that idea from a few angles. One voice pushes the ceiling concern. Another points out that Boise’s running game alone may not be enough against this defense. The debate gets more specific and more stubborn. They talk through the possibility of a 350-yard, three-touchdown kind of night and mostly decide that it does not feel realistic. They also note that Boise’s backfield gives Penn State a test it has not really seen this season. The show does not act like that detail is small. It just keeps returning to the same conclusion. Penn State’s defense looks like the deciding force, and a Penn State win is the likeliest outcome. The panel then starts imagining how the game will begin. Right-side off-tackle. A scripted first series. Drew Allar being asked to do just enough, maybe not much more than that. The whole thing becomes a running argument about whether Penn State can win comfortably without asking its quarterback to carry the load. By the close, the hosts are bargaining with the score line itself. They start wishing for an ugly, low-scoring game because that would preserve everybody’s pride. The final stretch turns into a comic standoff over what happens if Penn State loses or if Notre Dame enters the picture. Nobody wants to hand the other side an easy victory. The episode ends on that exact kind of college football tension, where the analysis is real but the loyalties are louder.

As heard by us

Messy playoff debate, real matchup talk, and enough chaos to keep it moving.

This review frames the episode as a blunt look at the first round of the College Football Playoff and the argument that followed, with rough games and rougher reactions left in plain view.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want the playoff arguments without the polite spin.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on