Is It Saturday Yet? A College Football Podcast · Student Union Sports

CFP Bracket Reaction + Army - Navy Game Preview

·1 hr 3 min·5 clips
SMU gets in over Alabama after a last-second loss, sparking a debate about playoff precedent and SEC bias.
Luke opens the show with Andrew Diaz and Bryce Hopwood, and the bracket immediately takes over. SMU getting in over Alabama becomes the first big argument, because SMU lost the conference championship game to Clemson on a last-second field goal and still made the field, which the crew treats as precedent for the next time the committee has to sort out a weird bracket. That is the headline. The hosts say future decisions are going to point back to this one, especially if the playoff keeps growing and the committee has to compare teams with different strength-of-schedule cases. Clemson still gets in as the ACC champ. The ACC ends up with two bids, the Big 12 gets one, and the conversation settles into the show's usual mode of arguing fairness, clarity, and committee logic all at once. Then they rewind championship weekend. Boise State's 21-7 win over UNLV gets a long look, with Genti's 209-yard, one-touchdown performance carrying the recap and the hosts landing on the blunt idea that Boise looks solid without sounding like a team they expect to win a playoff game. From there the show keeps moving into the playoff fallout and then into the Indiana discussion. The back half turns on Curtis, the Ohio State game, and the feeling that Indiana is up against a defense that can get after him, with one side of the conversation pointing to the pass rush, the spy, and the front, while the other side keeps pushing back on how long Indiana can hold up. That debate does not get tidy. Talk of a potential 17-point win hangs over the segment, and the crew keeps returning to the same pressure points before closing by saying next week will be the full college football playoff preview, with one pick on every game and three bowl games on the board as a bonus. The whole thing sounds like a college football group chat that knows the sport well enough to argue in specifics, even when the conversation veers hard into side roads.

As heard by us

Bracket chaos, precedent talk, and a trio that keeps the playoff debate moving.

This episode stays with college football's bracket mess, treating SMU over Alabama as the kind of committee call that can shape the whole conversation. Clemson, the ACC's two bids, and the Big 12 spot all get a fair shake, and the show does not pretend the picture is settled.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want the SMU-over-Alabama bracket fight while the playoff picture is still hot?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on