Irish History Podcast · Fin Dwyer

The Irish in America's Indian Wars: A Dark History

·51 min·3 clips
The episode begins with westward expansion and the violence it brought to Native Americans. It sets that alongside dispossession, forced removal to reservations, resistance, and the massacre at Wounded Knee in 1890. Then it turns toward Ireland. The host explains that poverty there helped send large numbers of Irish immigrants into the U.S. military, where they ended up present in some of the same dark chapters of U.S. history. The conversation sits with how hard that connection is to hold. People pushed from their own homes by poverty were also part of pushing Native Americans from theirs and taking part in massacres. Damien Shields joins to discuss his project on U.S. military pensions claimed in Ireland in the 19th and early 20th centuries. Those records offer a striking view into U.S. history, working-class Irish life, and the links between them. The discussion stays centered on the wars against Native Americans, which gives the episode its moral force. A letter tied to a veteran of Little Bighorn becomes one of the main windows into the material. He writes about Native Americans as being on the warpath, says they were surrounded at Little Bighorn, and later describes being promoted for meritorious conduct after helping a wounded man escape. Another passage shows how casually the language of conquest could travel back across the Atlantic. The episode also notes that these letters were read aloud in places such as Athlone and shared within communities. That local circulation mattered. It meant stories of U.S. campaigning did not stay abstract or distant, but entered ordinary Irish conversation and memory. The host returns to the larger historical question of what can be recovered from these pension files. The answer is not just names and service records, but a clearer sense of how empire, migration, class, and violence were connected. The episode closes by pointing listeners to the linked map, which makes those connections local and searchable.

As heard by us

A sober look at how Irish history sits inside the violence of U.S. expansion.

This episode traces how Irish poverty and U.S. expansion met on the frontier, and the result is hard to sit with. It links Native American dispossession and Irish enlistment in the U.S. military in a way that feels uneasy, but not forced.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the human cost behind Irish enlistment and America's wars against Native Americans.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on