Investing with IBD · Investor's Business Daily

Here’s How To Find An Edge In A Suddenly Uncrowded Market

March 18, 2026·56 min·5 clips
Jason Shapiro, an unknown Market Wizard, reveals his contrarian method for profiting when markets get too crowded.
Justin Nielsen opens live on a Wednesday, setting the session at 5 p.m. Eastern on March 18, 2026, with YouTube comments folded into the room. Jason Shapiro is back at the desk. Nielsen introduces him as founder of Crowded Markets Report, mentions his appearance in Schwager's Unknown Market Wizards series, and ties his contrarian method to the work of keeping institutional portfolios diversified. The conversation stays focused on process. Shapiro's approach is not sold as prediction magic. It is a way to think about positioning, diversification, and returns when the market is crowded or suddenly less crowded. Matt Caruso comes up briefly, with Nielsen noting that Caruso and Shapiro have teamed up on Markets Unscripted, which listeners in the comments seem to like. Then the episode gets more useful. Shapiro talks about trading with the assumption that being wrong comes with the job. The issue is whether the P and L can survive it. Being right can feel good, but the desk lesson is harsher: returns matter more than looking smart on one call. Nielsen presses him on missed trades, losses, and FOMO. Shapiro says he used to review that every day. For years, a full-time quant sat beside him, testing whether a missed trade or avoidable loss could have fit inside the rules. The guardrail was portfolio impact. Dodging one bad trade only mattered if the same parameter still worked across roughly a hundred trades, rather than fixing one painful example and breaking something else. That is the episode's practical core: a system can get worse when every regret turns into a tweak. The close shifts back to schedule, with Nielsen previewing more MarketSurge work, possible viewer questions, and Allie Quorum guest hosting while he is in Boston with his son.

As heard by us

A sober look at contrarian trading, where process and long-run P&L matter more than being right.

Jason Shapiro comes across as someone who cares more about keeping the book honest than sounding right. He keeps coming back to the same point: a bad trade only matters if it fits inside the larger framework, and the real test is whether a missed move would have mattered across…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A live Investing with IBD conversation with Jason Shapiro on contrarian market reads, P&L, and what to learn from wrong or missed trades.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on