playnext.fm

Into The Time Vortex - A Doctor Who Fan Podcast

2 Guys A Girl And A Podcast Episode 274 -Doctor Who -A Good Man Goes To War

·27 min·2 clips
The Doctor's friends' baby is stolen to be turned into a weapon against him.
The episode begins with an opening narration framing the Doctor as a 'mighty warrior' whose friends' baby is stolen to be turned into a weapon. Hosts Ken, Julia, and Annie start by reporting the death of actress Pamela Salem, known for Doctor Who roles and playing Miss Moneypenny in a James Bond film. They briefly discuss other shows they've been watching, including Masters of the Air and The New Look. The main discussion centers on 'A Good Man Goes to War,' with hosts praising Rory's character development into a 'badass' father determined to rescue his wife Amy and their baby. They highlight the emotional reunion of Rory and Amy, and the role of Lorna, a soldier who helps the Doctor after a childhood encounter but dies forgotten. Criticism emerges around Stephen Moffat's writing, with one host expressing frustration over Moffat lying about River Song's identity, which colors their view of the episode. The hosts debate the episode's overstuffed nature, feeling it brings back too many characters like Madame Vastra and Strax without clear purpose. They note the episode's high tension and action but argue it could have been simpler, focusing more on the core family drama. The convoluted River Song plot is criticized for being confusing and unnecessarily complex, with hosts pointing out unanswered questions like how River escapes prison. Overall, the discussion balances appreciation for character moments with critique of Moffat's narrative choices.

As heard by us

A Doctor Who review about fear, memory, returning faces, and a cliffhanger built for finale-level tension.

Doctor Who's "A Good Man Goes to War" gives Ken, Julia, and Annie a clean way into the Doctor's growing myth: a rescuer whose name is beginning to sound like a warning.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Doctor Who talk about a healer whose name is curdling into fear, a taken child, and a cliffhanger that feels like a season finale.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on
Apple PodcastsSpotify
Play clips from this episodeMore from Into The Time Vortex - A Doctor Who Fan Podcast