Inside Games News and Podcasts · Lawrence Sonntag

Is Marathon a Flop? - Inside Games Daily

March 25, 2026·21 min·1 clip
Marathon's PvP is so intense that new players get 'one punch to the gut after another'.
The episode opens with a sales estimate. Bungie's Marathon is said to have moved 1.2 million copies across Steam, Xbox, and PS5, and the hosts use that as the starting point for a sharp, funny conversation about whether the game is just underwhelming or genuinely in trouble. Their read is cautious skepticism. It is not painted as a Concord-level collapse, but it is also not the kind of number Bungie or PlayStation would have hoped for if things were going well. Then they move on. A Linear Analytics Substack post by Reese Elliott gives them a reason to look past the headline and get to the more interesting question: what is Marathon doing that keeps some players attached while others bounce off right away? That takes them into the loop. One host talks through solo queue friction, the annoyance of waiting a couple of minutes after a bad run, and the way Marathon still makes losing feel productive enough to queue again. That is the hook. Runs can still pay out progress through mission tasks, free kits, and a gear economy that keeps feeding you enough equipment that you do not treat every mid-range item like it belongs in a museum. The vault matters too. Because it fills up quickly, the game pushes players to take loot into the field instead of hoarding it, and that shifts the whole risk calculation in a way the hosts clearly find notable. Arc Raiders comes up as part of that comparison. They contrast Marathon’s softer landing on failure with the broader extraction-shooter debate around tension and gear fear, which helps them frame the game as something aimed at people who do not want suffering for its own sake. That point lands. One of them sounds genuinely sold on it, talking about wanting to reach Cryo Archive, needing better gear, and realizing the game has already hooked him by rewarding the stuff people usually pretend does not matter. The banter stays loose throughout. It keeps circling back to whether Marathon is being judged by the right standards, and the hosts keep nudging toward the same answer: the intended audience may be smaller than Bungie hoped, but the players who love it are deep in. The episode works because it treats sales data, design friction, and player taste as one argument instead of three separate headlines, so the conversation never gets stuck on the spreadsheet and never loses sight of what it actually feels like to play.

As heard by us

A sales check that turns into a blunt, mixed verdict on Marathon.

The discussion starts with the 1.2 million copy estimate across Steam, Xbox, and PS5, then uses that number to make a plain-spoken case for where Marathon stands. It calls the sales disappointing without turning the game into a total loss story.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want the case for why a game can look like a flop and still have real fans.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on