In Review – A Kinda Funny Film & TV Podcast · Kinda Funny

The Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the Ring - First Time Watching In Review

April 9, 2026·1 hr 39 min·5 clips
Cool Greg realized J.K. Rowling 'straight stole a lot of shit' from Lord of the Rings after watching Fellowship.
Nick Scarpino kicks off the segment in a rush. He fires off names, places, and Lord of the Rings fragments before the talk settles onto the movie itself. Andy Cortez is the voice across from him, and the show keeps that crowded-couch rhythm where everyone jumps in to correct, expand, or derail the point for a second. The discussion turns to the opening mythology. They revisit the idea that the rings were made for different powers and that one more ring was forged to control them all. Sauron becomes the next stop. They describe him standing huge over the field, rendered practically, taking broad swings at the humans around him. Isildur takes center stage. The panel walks through his role as the king of Gondor at the time, the final charge against Sauron and his minions, the cutting away of the ring, and the moment Sauron’s power collapses. Narsil matters too. The broken sword, the ring, and the chain of events around them get stitched together as the group talks it out. Mount Doom stays at the center. Elrond urges the ring’s destruction, but Isildur refuses at the edge of victory because he wants the thing for himself. The ring corrupts him immediately, and the story slides into the familiar disaster that follows. The pond image sticks. The group jokes about how much trouble could have been avoided if the ring had just been thrown into the lava. The talk keeps drifting. Those digressions run through name flubs, geography guesses, Galadriel, Minas Tirat, Buckleberry Ferry, and other loose bits of memory that keep the pace moving. The tone stays affectionate. It feels like a bunch of friends rediscovering a giant fantasy movie while the jokes, corrections, and nerdy callbacks keep the whole thing going. The episode ends on nostalgia. A middle-school memory about reading and watching that sequence gives the discussion a personal edge.

As heard by us

A chaotic Fellowship revisit that turns big lore into a funny, human hang.

This is a loud, affectionate Lord of the Rings chat that starts in joke mode and then settles into the saga's big beats: the opening war, the One Ring, Sauron's battlefield presence, and Isildur's refusal to destroy it.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a rowdy Fellowship-of-the-Ring revisit that still gets the big lore beats right.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on