A Cop's Promise

·45 min·2 clips

Daryl Smith gets 120 months in federal prison, with a release date of February 22, 2033.

1. Ice Cold Case turns to J.C. McGee's murder investigation in Belmont County, Ohio, and Madison McGee frames the episode around a new detective, Lieutenant Doug Cruz, and a stalled case update. 2. Madison McGee is the host and J.C. McGee's daughter, and Lieutenant Doug Cruz matters because he is the new investigator she finally reaches by phone. 3. The episode asks whether any real progress is happening, or whether the sheriff's department is still asking Madison to do the work they have avoided for 23 years. 4. Madison says she had to pause the show because each new lead sends her into either action or paralysis, and she records calls because she may not remember every detail later. 5. She cites Ohio one-party consent and says being in Austin, Texas also protected her right to record the conversation with Lieutenant Doug Cruz. 6. Cruz tells her he does not want to be on the podcast, but he still says he wants to work the case for her as a victim and family member. 7. Madison says the Belmont County Sheriff's Department later emails her for documents, names, and updates even though her transcripts, case files, and interviews are already public. 8. She says the county has asked for information she believes she has effectively already handed back to them through the podcast and website. 9. The episode then shifts to Daryl Smith, who the Department of Justice says was sentenced in late February to 120 months in federal prison for cocaine distribution. 10. Madison notes that Daryl's sentence includes prior drug and assault convictions, three years of supervised release, and a release date of February 22, 2033. 11. Because Daryl is in a federal prison in West Virginia, Madison has to use letters and an approved visitor list rather than the prison app she used before. 12. She jokes that she is becoming a prison pen pal while trying to reach a man she once considered a main suspect in J.C. McGee's murder. 13. Madison also says Omar is still a live lead, but he remains difficult to reach and keeps sending her inconsistent Facebook messages that start with "What's good, fam?" 14. A family member tells Madison a rumor that Omar was given a "mickey," and Madison explains that the theory would mean he was drugged and incapacitated that morning. 15. She questions that rumor by pointing out that someone sedated would not likely run down a hill, reach the brake shop, and still speak to 911. 16. Madison says Rico McGee is the other person she wants the sheriff's department to pursue, because he has told her he knows who killed her father. 17. Rico's silence leaves Madison frustrated, especially because she says police have not confirmed whether they have even reached out to him. 18. The episode's tone is blunt and defensive, with Madison repeatedly quoting police responses, reading public statements, and contrasting them with her own experience of waiting for answers. 19. Listeners who follow cold cases, police accountability, or J.C. McGee will find this useful. 20. Listeners wanting a tidy resolution or a standalone mystery probably should skip it.

As heard by us

A grieving investigation that finds its tension in delay, doubt, and stubborn follow-through.

Ice Cold Case comes back to Madison McGee's father's case after a long gap, and the pause hangs over everything. McGee treats the work as something lived through, not neatly solved, so the grief, pressure, and friction with family and police all stay in view.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want a cold case told like a live argument with the system.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Ice Cold Case