How to Buy a Home: The #1 First Time Home Buyer Podcast · David Sidoni

This ONE Myth is Killing First Time Homebuyers in 2026

·44 min·2 clips
Putting 20% down only changes a $500,000 payment by about $360 a month.
1. How to Buy a Home: The #1 First Time Home Buyer Podcast centers this episode on the claim that PMI is not the right enemy in 2026. 2. Host David Sedoni, a first-time homebuyer coach, says he has been doing this free for seven years and builds the episode around his own homebuying math. 3. The episode asks whether paying private mortgage insurance is a smarter path than waiting years to save 20% down. 4. Sedoni says rents have risen 165% since 2000 and 40% in the last five years, which is why he says the old no-PMI rule is outdated. 5. He defines PMI as private mortgage insurance on conventional loans with less than 20% down and contrasts it with homeowner's insurance inside PITI. 6. He says PMI is not permanent and usually disappears when a loan reaches 78% to 80% loan-to-value. 7. He gives a historical explanation for the 20% threshold, saying lenders created the rule for themselves as a safety cushion. 8. He argues that homes have historically appreciated about 3% to 4% a year and says that makes the lender's 20% demand look excessive. 9. He notes that military buyers using a VA loan can avoid PMI and may qualify with zero down. 10. He then gives a $300,000 to $700,000 range for typical PMI costs, with examples from $25 to $140 a month. 11. Sedoni walks through a $500,000 example at 6.25% and says 10% down produces a $3,325 monthly payment including PMI. 12. In that same example, he says 20% down lowers the payment to about $2,965, a difference of $360 a month. 13. He says the real cost of waiting can be larger than that monthly difference because a buyer may spend two years saving an extra $50,000 while paying rent. 14. He shows a low-down-payment strategy by saying 3% down starts at 97% loan-to-value and can drop to 80% in 3.78 years using a conservative appreciation model. 15. He says that same PMI would cost $2,880 over four years at $60 a month, while the home itself can build tens of thousands in wealth. 16. He also argues that keeping cash reserves can help buyers avoid feeling house poor, using the idea that $50,000 can cover the extra $360 payment for 138 months. 17. The tone is direct, math-heavy, and openly argumentative, with repeated claims that the episode is about facts rather than emotion. 18. The format is a solo teaching episode with repeated examples, rule lists, and references to episode 460, episode 426, and the episode guide. 19. Buyers comparing 10% down versus 20% down. 20. Anyone wanting emotional reassurance without spreadsheets.

As heard by us

PMI is reframed as leverage, not waste, for buyers navigating a tough 2026 market.

The episode argues firmly against treating PMI as a penalty. David Sedoni presents it as leverage rather than waste, and anchors that view in a 2026 market where rents and prices are up and rates still are not where buyers want them.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You need the math on PMI before you write off a starter home.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on