Hoosier Huddle Podcast · College Huddle

Hoosier Historia w/ Andy Graham: IU vs Illinois History

·52 min·4 clips
Antoine Randall-El fumbled the snap but turned it into a touchdown to win the 1999 IU-Illinois game in overtime.
Sammy Jacobs opens by saying they want to look back at two semi-recent Illinois-Indiana games that felt like classics. The 1999 overtime win comes first, and Antoine Randall-El's overtime winner is still the play everybody remembers. Then they jump to 2006 in Champaign, where Indiana won on Austin Starr's last-second field goal. Marcus Thigpen gets a nod for the role he played in that one. From there, the conversation shifts into the bigger rivalry picture. Andy and Sammy point out that Indiana and Illinois have played 74 times, and Indiana has not had the upper hand. They also note that Illinois has won three of the past four games. The tone stays conversational. Nobody stops to explain the basics. It stays centered on the details that matter to people who already know the series. Andy keeps circling back to Terry Hepner and what he meant to Indiana. He tells a story about ending up at a John Mellencamp concert at the Holman Center. A friend handed him tickets. He and Mike got there early. Rick Greenspan walked by first, and then Terry Hepner and his wife came through. Hepner and Jane ended up seated right next to them. Andy says the coach made them feel like they'd known him for years. That memory turns into a broader point about Hepner's personality and the kind of tenure he might have had if Indiana had kept him longer. The segment ends with a reminder that this rivalry has given Indiana recent wins too, including the 2013 and 2022 games, and that matchups like this are exactly why people buy tickets, head to the lot, and keep watching the Big Ten Network.

As heard by us

A rivalry-history conversation that makes old Indiana-Illinois finishes feel immediate again.

Hoosier Historia stays focused on Indiana's rivalry with Illinois by returning to two games that still carry the series: the 1999 overtime win on Antoine Randall-El's winner and the 2006 Champaign escape on Austin Starr's last-second field goal, with Marcus Thigpen in the mix.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For the Indiana-Illinois fan who wants the old rivalry and the famous finishes, with the history underneath.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on