Homecoming · Gimlet

2. PINEAPPLE

November 23, 2016·27 min·2 clips
Two soldiers realize the only proof they're in Florida is what they've been told.
The episode opens with Heidi Bergman on a rushed phone call juggling her brother Anthony and her boss Colin, establishing her as someone managing multiple competing demands. Heidi is based somewhere in the field — a cafeteria setting — and Colin is calling from Dubai. She shares a cafeteria audio recording with Colin through an archive interface, identifying the speakers as veterans Walter Cruz and Joseph Schreier, who are rooming together because they served in the same unit. In the recording, Cruz and Schreier are eating pineapple cobbler when Schreier methodically questions whether they are actually in Florida, since the only evidence is what program staff told them and palm trees are present in multiple regions. Schreier suggests they walk into town to verify, then argues that such an obvious test would have been anticipated and planned for. He asks Cruz rhetorically when anyone in power has genuinely cared about veterans, and the two realize neither clearly remembers receiving or choosing to accept orders to come to the facility. Colin's response to the recording is swift and authoritarian: Cruz is to be moved out of Schreier's room immediately, the room-sharing arrangement is to end, and if Schreier does not improve within 72 hours he will be reassigned. He frames Schreier as a liability who is 'contaminating the entire project.' Heidi attempts to push back gently but Colin does not engage with her clinical reasoning. In a separate thread, Heidi visits her mother Maria at what appears to be a care facility. Maria is resisting using her wheelchair. Their conversation drifts to Heidi's mysterious return from Tampa — Maria describes Heidi as having been shaky, quiet, and staring blankly at people. Heidi deflects. Maria tells a memory about a childhood horse trip in Wyoming where a young Heidi broke her arm and sat through the night with the bone protruding, setting her teeth against the pain until dawn. The session with Cruz involves him sharing self-reported memories. Cruz tells the Titanic Rising story: Lesky, a well-read soldier in their unit, convinced fellow soldier Benji — obsessed with the original Titanic — that a superior sequel existed. The prank expanded over weeks with the entire unit playing along and Lesky bribing the base PX staff to deny stocking the film because 'it was too emotional for soldiers.' The story is warm and specific. Cruz then reveals that Lesky was killed at the checkpoint by a vehicle some months later, leaving Benji without a resolution to the prank. Cruz's affect throughout is calm and deflecting — he calls the situation 'kind of annoying' and declines Heidi's offer to discuss Lesky's death more directly.

As heard by us

Routine talk keeps slipping into something harder to name.

Homecoming keeps routine coordination under pressure. Phone calls, check-ins, and family corrections keep bumping into each other until simple exchanges start to carry more weight than they should.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you like family damage hiding inside work calls, Pineapple stays tight.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on