Homebrewed Christianity

Community Over Cops: Building Justice from the Ground Up with Ross Halperin

·1 hr 7 min·5 clips
Investigative journalist Ross Halperin reveals how a shocking 60% of U.S. homicides go unsolved.
The episode focuses on the problem of building justice from the ground up. Ross Halperin describes a clandestine effort in Honduras that operated in the spaces between a community, the police, and prosecutors. The group knew where a culprit was. It could rent a car, put gas in it, and get someone there so an arrest could happen. When the case reached the initial audience, or arraignment, it could bring a witness and make sure that person was ready to testify. That arrangement put the group beside cops, prosecutors, witnesses, and informants. It also kept the work in the shadows, where the gang did not know what was happening. The early arrests show why this kind of structure could look effective. The episode gives just as much attention to the moral questions that came with that success. Working with the police could be necessary even when the police were not always effective or equal partners. That tension matters because many people in a middle-class American context assume that going to the police is obvious. The conversation widens from one case to the social trust that assumption depends on. It asks what happens when life teaches people otherwise. Honduras gives the question its sharper edge. The discussion describes a police force that Halperin says could arguably be the worst in the world. That claim is followed by a concrete detail: police stations had desks without computers. The image gives institutional failure a physical scale. It also keeps the conversation from treating police criticism as only an abstract American debate. Halperin's account stays in the uneasy middle ground where community action can involve state power without making the distrust or moral ambiguity disappear. The episode will interest listeners who want to think seriously about justice when trust is uneven and cooperation carries a cost.

As heard by us

A Honduras case study on gang arrests, scarce police resources, and the moral cost of working within broken trust.

This conversation with Ross Halperin looks at what justice can mean when police are neither reliable nor trusted partners. He follows a clandestine effort in Honduras that worked across police, prosecutors, witnesses, informants, and the community, even handling basics like…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to sit inside the shadow work of a Honduran community trying to make arrests possible when calling the police is not simple.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on