Holy Heretics: Losing Religion and Finding Jesus · The Sophia Society

Faith and Mental Illness: What I've Seen in Dark Places W/Anna Gazmarian

·37 min·2 clips

Anna says faith does not protect anyone from “deep pain” and that mental illness forced her to build more coping mechanisms.

1. Holy Heretics: Losing Religion and Finding Jesus centers on Anna Gazmarian’s memoir Devout: A Memoir of Doubt and her experience with mental illness and faith. 2. Gary Allen hosts Anna Gazmarian, an author whose essays have appeared in The Rumpus, Long Reads, The Sun, and The Guardian, and whose memoir frames the discussion. 3. The episode asks what happens when evangelical certainty collides with bipolar disorder, anxiety, and the need for a safer way to think about God. 4. Anna says she grew up in evangelical spaces that gave her community, purpose, and meaning, but also left her with no space for questions. 5. She describes legalistic Christianity as useful for her anxiety because it gave her checkboxes, while also feeding a constant sense that she was not enough for God. 6. Anna says she learned to see mental illness as sinful, demonic, and connected to suicidal thoughts, even though her parents supported ADHD and anxiety medication. 7. She says being diagnosed with bipolar disorder at 18 forced her to lose a worldview that no longer explained her life. 8. Anna connects her writing to prayer, saying she wants to be “unfiltered and honest” with God and to write the book she wished she had as a younger person. 9. She explains bipolar type two as hypomania and depression, with symptoms including staying up all night and then crashing into depression. 10. Anna says bipolar depression is difficult to treat and that medication can complicate symptoms rather than simply fix them. 11. She describes how John Piper’s warning not to “waste your life” made days spent in bed feel like spiritual failure. 12. Anna says depression produced self-loathing, shame, and guilt that she once treated as spiritually necessary rather than medically serious. 13. She says Jerusalem’s chapel dedicated to the loneliness of Jesus helped her see darkness as something that could connect her to Christ. 14. Anna argues that Jesus’s ministry focused on people outside religious circles, which shaped her view of who counts as devout. 15. She says doubt has deepened her picture of God by helping her reject ideas of God that were not serving her. 16. Anna says faith should involve critical thinking, uncertainty, and the freedom to ask, “God, like if you have the power to stop all of this, why don’t you?” 17. She says her therapist reacted strongly when she called depression beautiful, but she means that depression can sharpen her sense of light, love, and God in other people. 18. The interview style is conversational and personal, with Gary Allen sharing his own 2020 depression and Anna responding with specific examples from her life. 19. Listeners who question evangelical certainty and mental health stigma will likely connect with this episode. 20. Listeners wanting a purely doctrinal debate or quick answers may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Holy Heretics: Losing Religion and Finding Jesus