Hockey Night In New York - A New York Islanders Podcast · Hockey Night In New York

12/7/25 - Ain't No Joke! Guest: Arthur Staple, HNiNY

December 8, 2025·1 hr 20 min·5 clips

Arthur Staple says this may be the most consistency the Islanders are going to get.

Hockey Night in New York comes out swinging with the Islanders front and center. Sean Cuthbert welcomes listeners in with the sort of energy that assumes everybody already knows the stakes. Tony Stabile joins as the co-host for the night. Arthur Staple is teased as the upcoming guest, which sets the table for a conversation that stays rooted in Islanders talk and game-night banter. The episode keeps circling back to the Islanders' recent schedule. It walks through the stretch of wins and losses that have shaped the mood around the team. Tampa gets singled out as a strong response with two wins. Colorado also comes up as evidence that the Islanders can still handle top-end competition. Florida, St. Louis, and Boston are folded into the larger argument about games that were there to be taken but did not quite break the team's way. What the show emphasizes is how competitive the games have been. The Islanders are described as being in almost every game they play. That idea matters more than any single score line. Even the losses are framed with context, especially when empty-net goals make the final numbers look more lopsided than the game felt. The discussion does not pretend the club is perfect. It does, though, keep returning to the same basic point: they have not been getting buried. The tone stays conversational and quick. The hosts move from result to result without losing the thread. They treat standings pressure, opponent quality, and emotional carryover as part of the same hockey conversation. That makes the episode feel like a live read on the team rather than a static recap. Guest energy comes in as part of the structure rather than a hard reset. Arthur Staple's presence is used to deepen the Islanders talk, not replace it. Tony Stabile's return adds a familiar voice and gives the show a looser, more bar-room rhythm. The episode keeps its footing by coming back to what the Islanders have actually done, not just what they might do next. There is also a bit of room for the show to wander. Sponsor reads and a trivia-heavy close briefly interrupt the hockey flow. Even so, the episode keeps landing back on the same core subject. It wants to know whether the Islanders' recent form is a real sign of life or just a decent run inside a hard stretch. By the end, the show settles into its usual mix of fandom, memory, and judgment. It treats the Islanders like a team worth arguing about in real time. That is where this episode lives best: in the overlap between informed frustration and guarded belief.

As heard by us

A brisk Islanders hang that turns a busy stretch into real hockey context.

This episode keeps its eye on the Islanders' recent stretch and asks the useful questions: which losses actually mattered, which wins meant something, and how often this team is hanging around until the end.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Islanders talk from a live Sunday night show, with Tony Stabile in the seat and Arthur Staple joining in a few minutes.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Hockey Night In New York - A New York Islanders Podcast