History of the Papacy Podcast · History of the Papacy

A Priest, a Van, and a Team: Lessons from Buffalo’s East Side

·46 min·5 clips
This priest, built like Arnold Schwarzenegger, may be the only one in 2000 years of church history to join the weightlifting 'thousand pound club'.
Host Steve Guerra interviews Paul McCarthy, author of 'Don't Lose Your Dignity,' about his uncle Monsignor Leo McCarthy, a Catholic priest who spent 20 years coaching and mentoring youth in Buffalo's violent, impoverished East Side. The episode explores Father Leo's unconventional methods, the challenges he faced, and the tragic false accusations he endured during the priest abuse scandal.

As heard by us

A Buffalo priest used sports as pastoral care and earned lasting local respect.

The story presents Monsignor Leo McCarthy as a priest who used football and basketball to reach kids on Buffalo's East Side. Paul McCarthy describes him as someone who met young people where they already were and made discipline, dignity, and self-respect part of the lesson.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a priestly story told through football fields and basketball courts.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on