History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps · Peter Adamson

HoP 444 - The Dark Night Rises - Spanish Mysticism

·23 min·2 clips

In 16th-century Spain, a Franciscan reform movement promoted silent prayer, sparking fears of demonic deception.

The opening begins with quiet reading. Adamson takes the familiar story about antiquity and silent reading as a useful myth, then checks it against Augustine, Ambrose, and Plotinus before turning inward. The joke about Alexandria's imagined librarians lands lightly, but it has a job: it clears the way for a more serious question about interior acts in religious and philosophical life. Teresa arrives through discipline and reform. Like the Franciscan reforms already discussed, her Carmelite movement wanted stricter conduct, and the Discalced name made austerity plain enough. She spent much of her mature life traveling around Spain and founding new houses for the order. The autobiography is treated as more than life-writing. It is the story of a soul trying to find its proper relation with God. Augustine's Confessions gives her a partial model. Her early waywardness and later piety echo Augustine, though Adamson keeps that as influence, not a copy. Osuna gives her a language for the inward path. His stress on silent prayer, recollection, and self-abandonment lets Teresa describe devotion outside the world of learned letrados. That divide matters. Speculative theology belongs to the learned letrados; hidden or mystical theology runs through virtue and love of God. Teresa's exclusion is not background color. Osuna's distinction gives mystical practice a route for a woman blocked from learned theology. Books come out looking useful but secondary. Teresa nearly says so when she treats them as helps for people not yet ready for mental prayer. Suspicion still hangs over the achievement. Loyola's Spiritual Exercises, Teresa's autobiography, and John of the Cross's double treatise sit together as major Spanish mystical works, while Loyola's ideas, like Teresa's, were first treated as suspect. The church later embraces both Loyola and Teresa. Their canonization on March 12th, 1622 gives the story a neat institutional finish after all that uneasy interiority.

As heard by us

A myth about silent reading opens into a clear portrait of Teresa’s mystical reform.

It opens by clearing up a stubborn myth: antiquity did not ban silent reading, and Augustine’s note about Ambrose looks more like surprise than proof of a lost habit.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want silent reading, Teresa of Avila, and Spanish mysticism in one calm sweep, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps