History of North America · History of North America

492. Was Martin Frobisher a Pirate??

March 27, 2026·11 min·1 clip

Was Martin Frobisher a pirate or a knighted explorer searching for the Northwest Passage?

The episode opens by establishing the post-Columbian European obsession with finding a short route to Asia. Frobisher is introduced as an Elizabethan privateer knighted for service against the Spanish Armada in 1588. The narrator contextualizes the Northwest Passage search — Balboa and Magellan had found southern routes too long for early commerce. Frobisher first conceived of the Northwest Passage project in his youth and spent 15 years seeking backing before the 1576 voyage. His fleet for that voyage was strikingly small: three vessels totaling just 50 tons and 35 men, smaller than Columbus's fleet. On July 11, 1576, he sighted Greenland and then the continent beyond. Frobisher's crew made the first well-documented European contact with Inuit, who were observed in seal-skin kayaks and described in detail by the captain. Five of Frobisher's men were carried off by the Inuit and never seen again. Frobisher returned to England with a piece of glittering stone that London goldsmiths wrongly declared to be gold ore. Queen Elizabeth, hoping for treasure, provided a 180-ton ship called the Aid for a second voyage. On the second voyage, Frobisher discovered the strait now bearing his name, mistakenly believing the southern land was America and the north was Asia. Attempting to seize Inuit to conciliate them with gifts backfired, and he was shot with an arrow in his leg. His crew found European articles in Inuit kayaks and attacked in revenge for the lost men, with the Inuit fighting back fiercely. Two women were taken captive. A third voyage with a fleet of 15 ships brought back 200 tons of ore, but it was finally confirmed to be worthless pyrite. England lost interest in the Arctic. Frobisher pivoted to other naval ventures and died in 1594 from a wound in a naval battle off France. The episode closes with a brief description of Frobisher Bay in Nunavut, the inlet now bearing his name near the modern capital Iqaluit.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from History of North America