History in Reverse - Father and daughter science fiction podcast · History in Reverse SciFi Podcast

History in Reverse Sci-Fi Podcast Ep. 21: "Avatar: The Way of Water"

·1 hr 14 min·5 clips

Caroline reveals why Avatar 2's plot is so predictable that no moment surprises her.

This episode is an unscheduled review of the film *Avatar: The Way of Water* by the father-daughter hosts Richie and Caroline. They analyze the sequel's narrative and production after a 13-year gap since the original. The hosts note James Cameron stated he waited for technology to advance, though Caroline disputes the necessity. They recap the first film's plot involving Jake Sully transferring his consciousness into a Na'vi avatar and the conflict over unobtanium. The sequel begins over a decade later, with Jake and Neytiri raising three biological children and an adopted daughter, Kiri, born mysteriously from Grace Augustine's avatar. The human military returns, led by Colonel Miles Quaritch resurrected in a Na'vi body, seeking revenge on Jake's resistance. Jake's family flees to an oceanic Na'vi clan, where the sons befriend an outcast whale-like creature called a tulkun. A human boy named Spider, Quaritch's son, is captured but not meaningfully integrated into the colonel's arc. The film reveals the humans are hunting tulkun for a brain fluid that halts aging, a motive disclosed about 105 minutes into the runtime. The hosts highlight a scene where Kiri connects to an underwater tree and seizes, briefly speaking with her mother's spirit. Caroline finds the concept of a human mind transferring into a native body a problematic trope. She criticizes the inconsistent dialogue, where Na'vi children use modern slang like "dude" and "perv." Richie points out a visual detail where Jake's hybrid children have five fingers, unlike natural Na'vi. They both note Neytiri is sidelined with minimal dialogue and no training montage. The hosts are baffled by an antagonistic hissing encounter between Neytiri and the water clan leader's wife that goes nowhere. They call the introduction of a scantily clad teenage Na'vi girl a clichéd "sexy blue alien" moment. The whale-hunting sequence is described as a depressing *Moby-Dick* homage emphasizing that "whaling is bad." The tone is conversational, critical, and filled with humorous exasperation at the film's perceived flaws. The style is a recap and analysis interspersed with personal rants about narrative and character decisions. Fans of detailed film criticism and deconstruction of blockbuster storytelling would enjoy this episode. Listeners seeking a celebratory or spoiler-free review of *Avatar: The Way of Water* should skip it.

As heard by us

An enthusiastic, lightly critical talk about Avatar Way of Water that leans into the underwater world and the kids' story.

The conversation is openly excited about Avatar Way of Water after the long wait, and it keeps circling back to how the movie can feel ambitious and basic at the same time.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a blunt father-daughter debrief on Avatar Way of the Water, this is it.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from History in Reverse - Father and daughter science fiction podcast