Hillsdale Dialogues · Hillsdale College

The Road to the American Revolution, Part Three

·32 min·2 clips
Dean Matt Spalding links a recent anti-Semitic murder in D.C. to a rejection of America's founding equality principles.
This dialogue starts with current events before shifting into the historical frame of the American Revolution. Hewitt and Spalding discuss the murder of two young Jews who worked at the Israeli embassy in Washington, D.C., and the exchange quickly widens into the larger problem of antisemitism. From there, the conversation returns to the series' bigger task: recovering the road to independence without the comfort of hindsight. Spalding argues that history loses its shape when listeners assume the Constitution was inevitable. He insists that the Revolution and the Declaration become harder, and more interesting, when they are seen as unsettled choices rather than finished outcomes. Hewitt points listeners toward dramatized history as one way to make the period feel alive. He recommends the HBO series John Adams and notes that it dramatizes the events leading up to the first Continental Congress and the second Continental Congress. Spalding agrees that bringing history to life is difficult but worthwhile. The conversation then narrows to the people inside the story. John Adams, Sam Adams, John Dickinson, Thomas Jefferson, and Benjamin Franklin appear not as icons but as active participants in a tense political process. Spalding stresses that their decisions only make sense when listeners understand what each person knew and believed at the time. The point is not simply that they were brilliant. The point is that they were trying to solve real problems inside real institutions. The two hosts keep returning to the need to recover motives, pressures, and context. That approach turns the Revolution into a live argument rather than a settled myth. The conversation also makes room for the institutional setting of the Continental Congresses. Those gatherings were not scenes of simple unity. They were divided places where people worked through disagreements. Spalding says the period was feverish, but not revolutionary in the crude sense. He characterizes it as radical in a deliberate way. The episode closes by promising the next chapter of the series. That next discussion will cover the year from the election of George Washington through the Declaration of Independence.

As heard by us

A sharp reminder that revolutions are made in argument, not hindsight.

This episode makes a strong case against hindsight by following the first and second Continental Congresses and showing how uncertain the road to revolution really was.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want the first Congress before hindsight smooths it over?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on