Hillsdale Dialogues · Hillsdale College

The Road to the American Revolution, Part One

·34 min·3 clips
Thomas Paine's Common Sense sold 500,000 copies in a month, reaching a huge portion of the colonial population.
Hillsdale Dialogues pauses its Winston Churchill series for a couple of weeks to mark the 250th anniversary of the American Revolution. Hugh Hewitt opens by naming the anniversary and bringing in Matt Spaulding, dean of Hillsdale's Graduate School of Statesmanship in Washington, D.C. The episode starts with a broad question about where the revolution really begins. Spaulding reaches back to the French and Indian War as an early starting point. The colonies are still diverse at that stage. Scottish, Irish, English, German, and religious settlements shape different regions. The Puritans populate the northern colonies, and the colonies are very different in culture. The Atlantic gap with Britain gives them room to develop on their own terms. That distance does not create unity by itself. Unity comes later, under pressure. Hewitt presses Spaulding on how the founders were educated and formed. Spaulding answers through the larger civic formation of the era. Local legislatures, local taxation, juries, and legal practice help train political habits. British intervention changes those habits. As Parliament closes legislatures, overrides laws, refuses assent, and then taxes, resistance becomes more common. That resistance is not just defensive. It starts to make the colonies alike. Shared objections help produce a shared political identity. Spaulding argues that by 1776 the colonies can say, without exaggeration, that they are a people. Jefferson's Declaration gives that idea its famous expression. The episode closes by linking the revolutionary vocabulary to older constitutional language, including the claim that James II abdicated. The result is a beginning chapter that treats the Revolution as a long process of political consolidation rather than a sudden break.

As heard by us

A serious look at how the colonies came to share a common political identity.

The episode shifts from Churchill to the American Revolution and starts where the argument really has to begin: before 1776, when the colonies were still split by region, religion, and culture, and only slowly came to share a political identity.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Revolution before the slogans took over.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on