Hillsdale Dialogues · Hillsdale College

50 Years After the Fall of Saigon

·35 min·3 clips
Historian Mark Moyer explains why most books on the Vietnam War are wrong in many ways.
Hugh Hewitt opens by linking the fall of Saigon to other recent anniversaries, including Lexington and Concord and VE Day, and says the Saigon anniversary should not have been skipped over. Dr. Mark Moyer joins as the guest, introduced as a Vietnam War expert, an author of Triumph Forsaken and Triumph Regained, and a Hillsdale military history professor. The conversation turns to how the Vietnam War is remembered. Moyer argues that the historical record is fuller than many people think. North Vietnamese publications and military memoirs have provided usable material, and Chinese releases after the later split with Vietnam have added more. He also says there are still large gaps in the archive. Even so, he says the evidence still supports the revisionist view that the war was a worthy cause and could have been won. Hewitt brings up Max Hastings's Vietnam and Epic Tragedy and says he was disappointed by it. Moyer gives Hastings some credit for being more critical of the communists than some other writers, but says the book still misses too much. The conversation also turns to the romantic image of Ho Chi Minh, which Moyer rejects as too simple. The result is a brisk history discussion that keeps circling back to evidence, interpretation, and public memory.

As heard by us

A sharp Vietnam discussion that sets revisionist arguments against the war's familiar public memory.

This episode frames Vietnam as a conflict that still sits close to the surface in books, documents, and public memory. Mark Moyer makes the revisionist case for the war, while Hugh Hewitt keeps the exchange moving by pressing him on dates, titles, and competing readings of the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Vietnam War history discussed through documents, books, and military history.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on