Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns · Hidden Killers Podcast

Kelsey Fitzsimmons: When the Shooting Isn’t in Question — Just Where the Gun Was Pointed

·22 min·1 clip

Bob Mata says the situation escalated because Justin was brought to the house to get the baby.

1. Hidden Killers Live! focuses on the trial of Kelsey Fitzsimmons and the question of where the gun was pointed. 2. Tony Bruschi hosts the segment, and Bob Mata joins as a defense attorney because he breaks down the legal strategy and the police-procedure issues. 3. The episode asks whether this case is about an assault with a service weapon or a mental health crisis during a police encounter. 4. Mata says the first major decision was bench trial versus jury trial, and he says he prefers a judge when the case is a "he said and she said story." 5. He points out that there is no body-worn camera and that nobody else was in the room when the disputed moment happened. 6. Mata says a judge understands "beyond a reasonable doubt" and applies it to each element of each charge. 7. He says the Commonwealth still has to prove intent, not just that a gun was present. 8. The prosecution theory described on air is that Fitzsimmons raised her service weapon toward a fellow officer and pulled the trigger. 9. The defense theory described on air is that the gun never left her own temple and that the state is reframing a crisis as an assault. 10. Mata says the bench-trial setting removes some of the emotion that a jury might bring into the room. 11. He says the earlier judge was not friendly to the defense, and he notes that Judge Karp previously worked as both a prosecutor and a defense attorney. 12. Mata says that background on both sides of the aisle gives a judge different insight than someone who has only practiced one side. 13. He says the deadline in this kind of case becomes whether the judge believes Kelsey Fitzsimmons aimed the gun or whether reasonable doubt remains. 14. The discussion shifts to the ex parte restraining order and the removal of the child, which Mata says are often used as weapons in custody fights. 15. He says he has seen emails and text messages from Justin's mother to a police lieutenant in North Andover that suggest the family was pushing a narrative about Kelsey. 16. Mata says law enforcement was told Justin believed she might kill the baby, and he says that claim was not substantiated in the materials discussed. 17. He says bringing Justin to the house to collect the baby was "insane" and that a social worker should have handled the removal. 18. The segment sounds conversational and argumentative, with Tony Bruschi pressing questions and Mata answering in a rapid back-and-forth format. 19. Listeners interested in Massachusetts criminal cases and police-procedure disputes. 20. Listeners looking for a simple true-crime recap without legal detail.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns