Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns · Hidden Killers Podcast

Kelsey Fitzsimmons: How a Postpartum Depression Crisis Became a Felony Assault Charge

·20 min·1 clip

Kelsey Fitzsimmons was on medical leave for postpartum depression when a colleague came to hand her a restraining order and take her baby.

1. Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns centers on Kelsey Fitzsimmons and the felony assault charge tied to a postpartum depression crisis. 2. Tony Bruschi hosts the segment, with Robin Vree and Jennifer Coffendaffer joining as retired FBI special agents who analyze police procedure and use-of-force issues. 3. The episode asks whether a mental-health welfare response and a restraining-order service call were handled in a way that made the situation worse. 4. Tony says Fitzsimmons was a new mother on medical leave for postpartum depression when her fiancé went to court and said he feared for his child's life. 5. The timeline includes June 30, 2025, when her own colleague arrived to hand her a restraining order and take her baby. 6. Tony states that she was shot in the chest and now faces a bench trial on assault with a dangerous weapon. 7. Tony says the charge could send her to prison for up to five years, while her ex faces no criminal exposure in the episode's framing. 8. Jennifer says she wants every arrest report to end with "arrested without incident," and she says that did not happen here. 9. Robin says the department's normal protocol for serving a warrant or restraining order is usually two people, but three were sent in this case. 10. Robin notes that the officer who confronted Fitzsimmons had 20 years on the force and that "everyone knew each other." 11. Jennifer says that if she were supervising the operation, she would have called Fitzsimmons out instead of serving the paperwork at the door. 12. Jennifer describes postpartum depression as a state where a mother can be "not in their right mind" and at the "brink of their emotional envelope." 13. Robin says the officers may have treated the matter like "just a restraining order" and underestimated the possible consequences. 14. Jennifer says the lethal-force decision was reasonable in the moment because a loaded gun in her hand created an immediate threat. 15. Robin mentions that the first shot allegedly jammed and that the tap-rack-bang clearing action changed the confrontation. 16. Jennifer says Fitzsimmons asked for a bench trial, which suggests she thinks she can explain her actions to a judge. 17. The discussion returns several times to the contrast between hindsight and the legal standard that judges must apply in real time. 18. The tone is analytical and conversational, with the hosts debating police procedure, mental health, and courtroom strategy. 19. Viewers interested in police procedure, postpartum mental health, and criminal charges. 20. Listeners wanting a light, entertainment-first true-crime format.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Hidden Killers Live! Daily True Crime News & Breakdowns