Heroes & Zeros- A True Crime Podcast · Annie Weaver

Episode 69 Roy Nellsch is a Zero

·17 min·1 clip
Abby Pimentel lunged with a blanket, choked her kidnapper, and tried to tip the semi-truck over while it sped down the highway.
Annie opens with an ongoing investigation. She frames Abby Pimentel as the hero and Roy Nelsch as the zero, then goes straight into the roadside crisis that started on May 21, 2019. Abby is driving on I-24 near the Kentucky-Tennessee border when her car runs out of gas. According to her account, the battery is dead and the phone is dead too, leaving her stuck in traffic like a sitting duck. A semi does a U-turn and pulls over to offer help. That act of help becomes the center of the kidnapping and assault case the episode follows through the police response, the survivor account, and the arrest. Annie credits reporting from Jeremy Finley of News 4 Investigates. Detective Dennis Honholt learns on May 22 that a truck driver has been arrested. He then sits through a five-hour interrogation with Nelsch and hears a version of events that sharply conflicts with Abby's account. Honholt walks Nelsch back through Abby's statement, which says she fought with him, got a gun from him, and managed to run for help. Nelsch pushes back and says he was the real victim, claiming Abby threatened to accuse him of rape unless he gave her money. Annie presents that as part of Nelsch's attempt to explain himself, not as a clean answer. Honholt says his first thought was that Nelsch seemed like a serial killer. He also says the man looked very well rehearsed as the account unfolded. The episode also brings in Nelsch's anonymous girlfriend, who says they met through an unusual Craigslist ad for a rape fantasy, adding another disturbing layer to an already grim case. Annie closes by telling listeners that more information may come later, so for now the episode stays with Abby at the center, Nelsch under scrutiny, and the case still open.

As heard by us

A tense roadside case with a blunt, survivor-centered moral line.

This episode gives the roadside kidnapping and assault case real force by keeping Abby Pimentel and Roy Nelsch at the center. The writing stays plainspoken and measured, which suits an active investigation, and the timeline is easy to track without softening the stakes.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

An ongoing true-crime investigation that keeps Abby Pimentel's account and Roy Nelsch's interrogation at the center.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on