HerMoney with Jean Chatzky

"My kids don't need their college savings anymore. Can I keep the tax benefits?"

·23 min·2 clips
Jean Chatzky reveals the moment financial rules go silent and parental tension takes over during a child's college decisions.
The host opens Mailbag by returning to a familiar personal-finance rule: college can be funded with borrowing, while retirement cannot. A listener's question puts that rule up against a sizable 529 balance and the worry of making an expensive wrong move. The discussion keeps the possible 10 percent penalty in perspective. The episode explains that the penalty applies to profits from a withdrawal, not to the entire amount withdrawn. In a $65,000 withdrawal example, $45,000 is treated as contributions and $20,000 as profit. That math leads to a $2,000 penalty on the profit portion. The amount still matters, but the example keeps the focus where it belongs: on the earnings portion. The conversation then adds a second guardrail for financial advice. Listeners are encouraged to ask whether an advisor is acting as a fiduciary and how that advisor is compensated. Commission is presented as a possible conflict of interest even when a recommendation is allowed. The point is less dramatic than practical: know the advisor's role and the standard being used. A second Mailbag letter starts with a household milestone. The family has finished daycare payments starting in June and paid off the husband's student loan early. The letter gives a combined gross income of $155,000 for two 37-year-olds with two young kids. It then lays out 403b contributions at 9 percent, a 5 percent employer match, monthly 457 contributions, and a pretax supplemental retirement account. The household also puts $200 each month into each child's 529 account. Its remaining obligations include a $75,000 mortgage at 3.5 percent and an $18,000 car loan at zero percent interest. Savings for home repairs and emergencies, plus supplemental term life and disability insurance, help round out the retirement advisor's view that the pair is on track to retire comfortably at 59. The episode leaves a practical picture of how one tax question can sit inside a much larger household plan.

As heard by us

A 529 withdrawal question is clearest when the penalty is tied to earnings, not the full withdrawal.

College savings are most revealing when a family has to decide how carefully to handle money inside a 529 plan. This Mailbag episode follows a question about the same beneficiary and a sizable balance, then lands on the useful math: the 10 percent penalty applies to earnings,…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a calm read on a 529 decision where the headline penalty is not the whole story.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on