Here's How ::: Ireland's Political, Social and Current Affairs Podcast · William Campbell

Threats to Democracy

·36 min·2 clips
Compared to anyone anywhere on Earth in any era, William Campbell says people alive in Ireland today are among the luckiest ever.
1. Episode 177 of Here's How, dated 19 December 2024, uses a self-built spreadsheet to test whether democracy correlates with prosperity, health and education across more than 150 countries. 2. William Campbell presents and Kevin Wolf, the co-producer, questions him in the closing Q&A about his method and the post-election turnout. 3. Campbell frames the episode around Peter Thiel's written view that democracy is not compatible with freedom, noting Thiel selected J.D. Vance as Donald Trump's vice president. 4. He opens by congratulating all 686 election candidates, from Pearse Doherty's 18,898 first preferences in Donegal to Sean O'Leary's nine votes in Wicklow, and says 512 candidates were not elected. 5. He describes the anti-democratic argument that an "ignorant, fickle public" slows progress and may outvote a productive minority, and notes similar strains in fundamentalist Islam and in Catholic Church support for Mussolini's model. 6. His control tests showed alphabetical order correlating at -0.03 with democracy rank and population at -0.14, while GDP (0.66), HDI (0.65), Quality of Life (0.74), maternal mortality (0.55), infant mortality (0.62) and life expectancy (0.61) all correlated strongly. 7. Press freedom and economic freedom both correlated at 0.77, PISA overall at about 0.54, the Good Country Index at 0.62 and average height at 0.44, which Campbell summarises as "democracy makes you taller." 8. Campbell ranks Ireland 2nd for reading and 2nd for GDP per person, 8th for press freedom and the Good Country Index, and says Ireland beats the UK on every index he used. 9. Kevin Wolf raises the point that press freedom and democracy partly measure the same thing, and Campbell agrees, citing economic freedom as the most extreme case while defending infant mortality and height as culturally neutral measures. 10. Suited to listeners who enjoy data-driven political argument and Irish current affairs.
Listen to the show on