Here's How ::: Ireland's Political, Social and Current Affairs Podcast · William Campbell

Medieval Attitudes

·1 hr 7 min·4 clips
The researchers say 49.2% of Irish Christian respondents viewed Jews as more loyal to Israel.
1. Here's How, presented by William Campbell, examines medieval attitudes toward Jews in Ireland and modern arguments about Irish anti-Semitism. 2. William Campbell hosts Kirill Bumin and Mordechai in Barry, academics whose survey measures Christian-Jewish attitudes and views of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. 3. The episode asks whether Irish sympathy for Palestinians reflects anti-Semitism, criticism of Israeli policy, historical memory, or several overlapping attitudes. 4. Campbell cites Justin Barrett's exchange with Rebel News at an anti-immigration march as an example of Irish anti-Semitic rhetoric combining far-right politics and conservative Catholic theology. 5. Campbell argues that Ireland's small Jewish population limited direct anti-Jewish conflict and that Ireland's neutrality during World War II reduced public exposure to the Holocaust. 6. Lisa Leal's Times of Israel article is presented as an example of claims that Irish Christianity remains closer to medieval attitudes toward Jews. 7. Bumin and Barry's polling found Irish Christians more likely to express anti-Semitic opinions than respondents in the United States and United Kingdom. 8. Campbell accepts the poll's methodology but questions its representativeness because 11.7% of respondents belonged to the Church of Ireland compared with 2.5% in the census. 9. Campbell also notes that 14% identified as another Protestant or Orthodox denomination, although those groups represented about 4% of the census population. 10. Bumin reports that 58.5% agreed with Leo Varadkar's comparison between Irish and Palestinian experiences of displacement, dispossession, discrimination, and hunger. 11. Barry says 49.2% of Irish Christian respondents believed Jews were more loyal to Israel, a result he calls troubling. 12. The researchers also report that 64% described Israel's conduct in Gaza as genocide and 60% believed Palestinian civilians were deliberately targeted. 13. Campbell argues that sympathy for suffering Palestinians does not itself establish hostility toward Jews or support for anti-Semitic ideas. 14. Bumin distinguishes anti-Israel criticism from denying Israel's right to exist while granting national self-determination to other peoples. 15. Campbell cites Daniel O'Connell's support for Jewish emancipation, Jewish mayors Bob Briscoe and Ben Briscoe, and Jewish cabinet ministers as evidence of Irish civic inclusion. 16. The discussion also covers the Limerick boycott, Arthur Griffith's anti-Dreyfus politics, and the abstract nature of prejudice against a small Jewish community. 17. Campbell repeatedly interrupts the interview to separate empirical survey questions from partisan arguments about Israel, Iran, Hamas, Hezbollah, and the Houthis. 18. The format is a contested academic interview in which Campbell tests the researchers' sample, definitions, historical comparisons, and interpretation of survey responses. 19. Irish history and Israeli-Palestinian debate listeners seeking survey evidence. 20. Listeners uninterested in politics, polling, religion, or historical argument.
Listen to the show on