HELP! I Suck at Dating · iHeartPodcasts

“Incidental Child Abuse”; Judge Refuses to Let Taylor Frankie Paul See Her Kid Unsupervised

April 7, 2026·24 min·2 clips
A judge describes Taylor Frankie Paul pushing her ex while he held their newborn, risking the baby's safety.
1. Amy and TJ covers the April 7 court hearing between Taylor Frankie Paul and ex-partner Dakota Mortensen, focused on custody of their two-year-old son Ever. 2. Amy Robach and TJ Holmes co-host the Amy and TJ podcast on the iHeart network; both are former national TV journalists. 3. The episode's core question is whether Taylor Frankie Paul would regain unsupervised visitation rights to her son, which had been stripped by a temporary protective order Dakota filed after videos of aggressive incidents became public. 4. Before all the legal action, Taylor Frankie Paul had Ever approximately 70% of the time under a shared custody arrangement and was the primary parental figure in his daily life. 5. Dakota's attorneys argued in court that he has been the sole caregiver for months because Taylor had been out of town for extended periods, a detail the hosts say they had not previously known. 6. The judge granted Taylor up to eight hours per week of supervised visitation — initially offering six hours before agreeing to eight after her attorneys pushed back — a significant reduction from her prior primary custody arrangement. 7. A lengthy argument followed over who should serve as the independent supervisor during Taylor's visits: her choice of person, his choice, or a court-appointed independent monitor. The judge ultimately favored an independent monitor. 8. A previously unreported 2024 video was referenced in court, in which Taylor reportedly kicked in the door of her sleeping infant's room and pushed Dakota with such force that he nearly fell while holding then-infant Ever. 9. The hosts note that at the time of the 2024 incident, Ever would have been months old — not the toddler he is now — making the potential for harm significantly greater. 10. The judge quoted in court: 'There doesn't seem to be any thought put into the effect this might have upon the child,' and said the behavior was very troubling regardless of whether Dakota had provoked a reaction. 11. Taylor's attorney argued that her anger has been unambiguously directed at Dakota and not at the children, but the hosts note that the phrasing 'deliberately' abusive toward children was undercut by the 2023 video in which her older daughter was struck by a metal chair — and she did not stop to check on her. 12. The 2023 incident that led to Taylor losing the Bachelorette role, the 2024 incidents involving Ever as an infant, and the February 2026 incidents are now three separate clusters of alleged behavior the judge is weighing. 13. Taylor Frankie Paul filed her own temporary restraining order against Dakota on the morning of the court hearing, alleging he drove away with her against her will, slammed her head against the dashboard, and punched her in the knee and elbow. 14. Her attorneys provided photos of alleged injuries and texts sent immediately after the incident as supporting evidence in the TRO filing. 15. The hosts interpret the timing of Taylor's TRO filing as a deliberate media strategy: by filing just before the court proceeding, her legal team ensured it would enter public conversation alongside her courtroom loss. 16. Dakota's attorneys characterized the ongoing pattern by saying Taylor is always the aggressor, while Taylor's attorneys countered that Dakota is skilled at provoking reactions and that as long as they stay apart, there is no risk to the child. 17. The hosts discuss how the Bachelorette season would have collapsed regardless of when the videos emerged — either before it started or mid-season — and note that online audiences are still seeking clips of what the season would have looked like. 18. The episode has a conversational analytical tone; the hosts react to details in real time, express genuine surprise at new facts, and occasionally inject dry humor while treating the child-safety elements seriously. 19. Listeners who follow celebrity legal news, The Bachelor franchise, or the Taylor Frankie Paul story will find this useful for understanding the court ruling and new allegations. 20. Listeners seeking deep legal analysis, official court documents, or coverage of topics unrelated to celebrity gossip and reality TV will not find this episode useful.

As heard by us

A custody dispute stays lively while keeping the child's safety at the center.

The segment moves at a quick, conversational pace, but it keeps coming back to one thing: a child should not be caught in the middle of an adult blowup.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the custody fallout without the courtroom jargon or PR polish.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on