Hello From The Magic Tavern · Arnie Niekamp

BONUS: Introducing No Skip Christmas - Justin McElroy

November 27, 2025·59 min·5 clips

Arnie defends 'Holly Jolly Christmas' as a nostalgic standard, while Justin argues it's too tied to Rudolph to stand alone.

A tavern-weary narrator opens with magical objects and Indicloud. The ad bit has one boot in the tavern and one in sponsor land, with crystals, orbs, gummies, sodas, surveys, and responsible choices all rattling around together. Then the show turns. The main conversation is about Low's Just Like Christmas, remembered through a cardboard EP, a basement milk crate, and a personal canon that has clearly dug in. It starts with bells. That detail gets treated seriously, because jingling bells can make a song feel Christmas-adjacent before anything else has happened. The song itself stays small. There is a drum-machine feel, a beautiful organ, and Mimi Parker's voice moving through spare travel images in Stockholm and Oslo. Snow shows up, then disappears. Beds are too small, roads go wrong, and the feeling still drifts back toward Christmas instead of away from it. Justin has not heard the song before, but he picks up the ache in it: wanting the holiday while the holiday is already happening. That is the odd little trick. The episode sits with that feeling without buffing it into holiday-card sentiment. It stays warm, loose, and talky, with enough strange phrasing to keep the sweetness from going glossy. The ending turns practical, pointing listeners to show notes, accepted songs, rejected songs, episode playlists, and another conversation with Helen Zaltzman. Tuesdays keep moving Christmasward. By the end, it feels less like a grand quest than a shared playlist, where one small song earns its spot by making longing feel bright.

As heard by us

A Christmas-song case for tunes that feel wistful as well as seasonal.

This bonus episode makes a clear case for Christmas songs that lean wistful instead of glossy. Justin McElroy keeps coming back to Low's "Just Like Christmas," and the charm is in the small details he notices: the jingling bells, the radio-like drum machine, the organ, and the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Justin McElroy makes a case for the bittersweet pull of Low's "Just Like Christmas."

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Hello From The Magic Tavern