playnext.fm

Hack or Slash - A Horror Movie Review Podcast · Hack or Slash

Black Phone 2 (2025)

October 24, 2025·1 hr 24 min·8 clips
The young leads' emotional evolution makes Black Phone 2 worth the sequel risk.
Chris opens with spooky-season energy and the crew slides into Black Phone 2 fast. The discussion has a horror argument feel from the start. They spend a lot of time on what counts as a kill, which is exactly the kind of ridiculous technicality this show can make fun of. Three of the deaths sit in the past and get unpacked as the story moves forward, while the film also shows the death of Finney and Gwen's mom and then the final technicality around the Grabber. That gives the conversation a mystery shape instead of a plain recap. The hosts are into the ghost-kid dream imagery because it gets properly nasty, and they compare it to sinister snuff-film energy more than clean jump scares. Binks keeps pushing the idea that the sequel could have committed harder. The conversation keeps circling back to whether the movie held back when the setup suggested more escalation. The panel also jokes around the franchise mythology without losing the thread. The Grabber's return is treated as a technicality that is strange enough to be worth arguing over. That keeps the tone playful even when the movie is doing grim stuff. By the end of the review, the question is whether Black Phone 2 earns its own haunted logic. Then the B-side kicks in and the show pivots to the real horror of phone calls themselves. That side conversation fits the episode because it turns one movie review into a broader genre riff. It sounds like a group of horror fans talking it through in real time, with the jokes and critique staying in the same lane. It is a good fit for listeners who want their sequel talk messy, funny, and specific.

As heard by us

A funny, sharp sequel debate that treats kill counts and horror rules like serious business.

Hacker Slash treats Black Phone 2 as a spoiler-heavy sequel argument, weighing what counts as a kill, what belongs to the past, and how the movie folds older deaths into fresh nightmare logic.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a spoiler-zone horror review that counts the kills and argues the rules.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on
Apple PodcastsSpotify
Play clips from this episodeMore from Hack or Slash - A Horror Movie Review Podcast