Givers, Doers, & Thinkers—A Podcast on Philanthropy and Civil Society · Jeremy Beer

Matthew Crawford & the rise of the Humanitarian Party

·42 min·2 clips

Crawford argues sovereignty has migrated from representative government to corporations, foundations, media, universities, and NGOs.

1. Givers, Doers, & Thinkers speaks with Matthew Crawford about “the rise of the Humanitarian Party” and what it means for civil society and self-governance. 2. Jeremy Beer hosts from Phoenix, Arizona, and Crawford joins from San Jose, California, bringing books like Shop Class as Soulcraft, A World Beyond Your Head, and Why We Drive. 3. The episode asks what happened to sovereignty when corporations, foundations, media, universities, and NGOs began acting like a political force outside the state. 4. Crawford says liberal democracy once imagined sovereignty as lying with “the people,” but representation in a large society has shifted power away from parliamentary bodies. 5. He links that shift to COVID, where “expert jurisdiction” reached “every domain of life” without passing ordinary laws. 6. Crawford describes that COVID coordination as a parastate that made it obvious where “right opinion” lay for the prestige class. 7. He says democratic pushback was often treated as populism and then re-described as a threat to democracy. 8. Crawford argues that elite formation through universities and other gatekeeping institutions has produced a more hegemonic set of opinions. 9. He says shared signaling, not a “smoke-filled room” conspiracy, helps corporations, foundations, and universities coordinate. 10. Crawford names the “humanitarian party” as the better label for this state-like coalition and says it expands through the “woke revolution” and technical expertise. 11. He traces the expertise side to Christopher Lasch and to the “colonization of the life world” by child-rearing advice, home economics, and sex education. 12. He says both expertise and woke politics displace common sense, delegitimize ordinary practice, and enlarge managerial authority. 13. Crawford says compassion can be used as a weapon when sexual minorities, racial minorities, the immunocompromised, or climate refugees are adopted as clients. 14. He argues that these groups can become mascots for programs of social control and a “subterranean class war.” 15. He connects that logic to the Americans with Disabilities Act and to long COVID as an example of an oppositional identity being formed through legal categories. 16. Crawford says the dynamic can continue through recurring “moral emergencies,” from white supremacy to COVID. 17. On driverless cars, he says Google’s early self-driving prototype stalled at a four-way stop because it could not read the social intelligence of human drivers. 18. Crawford uses that anecdote to argue that everyday improvisation and cooperation form democratic character better than rule-following machines. 19. He and Beer keep the conversation interview-driven and analytical, with concrete examples, repeated back-and-forth clarification, and a restrained tone. 20. Listeners interested in civil society, technology, education, and social theory will get the most from it; listeners wanting a light or purely biographical chat may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Givers, Doers, & Thinkers—A Podcast on Philanthropy and Civil Society