Give an Ovation: The Restaurant Guest Experience Podcast with Zack Oates · Ovation

Using Feedback to Stay Competitive with Gregory Zamfotis of Gregorys Coffee

December 15, 2025·28 min·2 clips
Gregory's Coffee cut its top-selling donuts, based on 55-year-old family recipes, to bake pastries fresh in-store.
1. Zach Oates hosts Gregory Zamfotis, founder of Gregory's Coffee, on Give An Ovation to discuss guest experience strategy at a growing New York City coffee chain. 2. Gregory Zamfotis founded Gregory's Coffee in 2006 and has scaled it from New York and DC metro locations to national mall presence via a partnership with Assignment Property Group that converted several Starbucks locations. 3. The episode's core thesis is that fast service and high quality are not mutually exclusive, and that feedback is the mechanism that keeps both from slipping. 4. Zamfotis grew up working in his father's panini press sandwich shop in the Freehold Raceway Mall food court in New Jersey, which he credits as his real-world business education. 5. The Gregory's Coffee logo is a caricature of Zamfotis himself — his glasses and hair — and the brand name intentionally omits an apostrophe to signal that the chain belongs to customers, not the founder. 6. Zamfotis says Starbucks was named after the first mate Starbuck in Moby Dick, which he learned only while researching for the podcast, despite having read two books about the company. 7. The core Gregory's Coffee philosophy is that New York City lunch-rush speed drilled into Zamfotis by his father — 'crush the lunch rush or lose the business' — translates directly to coffee: speed and quality together, not speed instead of quality. 8. Gregory's competed with specialty coffee chains by asking 'why does a customer have to sacrifice quality just because they want it quicker,' and built systems to deliver high-end coffee in the fastest time possible. 9. Zamfotis eliminated three top-five selling baked goods — a sourdough glazed donut, whole wheat chai donut, and apple fritter — all from 55-year-old recipes his father created after dropping out of Brooklyn College in the 1970s to run a South Brooklyn donut shop. 10. The donuts were cut because moving baking in-store required ovens, not fryers; the trade-off was croissants baked 30-45 minutes before service replacing products made 12-18 hours earlier at a central commissary. 11. Zamfotis describes a team leader named Cindy at a DC location who despite limited English confidence consistently produces a perfect pastry case because she adds 30 extra seconds of browning time by instinct — representing the quality culture he wants across all stores. 12. He says he promoted Cindy even when she didn't believe she could advance, arguing that demonstrated care and results matter more than language confidence. 13. Zamfotis describes getting behind the espresso bar when visiting stores, sometimes ruining a white shirt and tie before a lawyer meeting, as a deliberate signal that no task is beneath him. 14. He says he wants to measure daily Net Promoter Scores for his own team — tracking how employees feel at the start versus end of a shift — arguing that a drop from nine to six signals a management problem. 15. His first Yelp review was a three-star complaint about crumbs on a table at his first store; he called Yelp to demand it be removed and was told no, an experience he now calls the beginning of his feedback education. 16. He describes negative reviews as 'a free secret shopper report' and says a competitor opening next door is often a signal that the competitor perceived weakness in your operation. 17. Oates and Zamfotis built a 'call to tech' phone solution together after Gregory's raised the idea three years into their Ovation partnership, described as one of the product innovations that came from operator collaboration. 18. The conversation's tone is collegial and practical — two operators who have worked together for four years comparing frameworks rather than pitching. 19. Multi-unit restaurant operators and coffee industry professionals interested in scaling quality while maintaining throughput will find this useful. 20. Listeners expecting consumer-facing coffee culture content rather than operational and franchise strategy discussion may find the focus too business-oriented.

As heard by us

A practical look at the tradeoffs behind growth, consistency, and guest experience.

Greg Zemfotis and Gregory's Coffee read as a clear case study in the tension between growth and guest experience. The discussion is strongest when it gets concrete about moving away from donuts that had long been made from scratch in a commissary, so production could shift…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Hear how Gregory's Coffee weighed efficiency against guest experience.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on