Gil's Arena · Underdog Fantasy

James Harden's SURPRISE Trade Request STUNS Gil's Arena

February 3, 2026·1 hr 28 min·7 clips

Kawhi Leonard is averaging 28 points on 50/39/91 shooting splits with a league-leading 2.1 steals — the first player in NBA history with those numbers to be excluded from the All-Star Game.

1. Gil's Arena, Episode covering NBA trade deadline week, features host Josiah Johnson with Gilbert Arenas, Nick Young, Rashad McCants, and Brandon Jennings. 2. The panelists are respectively an NBA legend, an NBA champion, an NCAA champion, and a veteran NBA point guard; host Josiah Johnson serves as moderator. 3. The episode addresses three topics: James Harden's reported trade from the LA Clippers, Paul George's 25-game suspension for drug policy violation, and the just-released All-Star Game reserves. 4. East reserves named include Scottie Barnes, Jalen Duren, Jalen Johnson, Donovan Mitchell, Norman Powell, Pascal Siakam, and Karl-Anthony Towns, joining starters Cade Cunningham, Tyrese Maxey, Jalen Brunson, Jalen Brown, and Giannis Antetokounmpo. 5. West reserves include Danny Avdia, Devin Booker, Kevin Durant, Anthony Edwards, Chet Holmgren, LeBron James, and Jamal Murray, joining starters Nikola Jokic, Luka Doncic, SGA, Steph Curry, and Victor Wembanyama. 6. Gil argues the All-Star Game has declined because the 80s and 90s rosters were composed entirely of clear number-one options on their teams, whereas today's expanded 24-man format requires filling spots with second and third options. 7. Notable snubs discussed include Michael Porter Jr. (averaging 26 points, 7 rebounds, 3 assists at career highs), Joel Embiid (26 points, 7 rebounds in 29 games), Bam Adebayo (18 and 10), Brandon Ingram, and Kawhi Leonard. 8. Kawhi Leonard's snub draws the sharpest analysis: he is averaging a career-high 28 points on 50/39/91 shooting splits, 6 rebounds, 4 assists, and a league-leading 2.1 steals — identified as the first player in NBA history to average those numbers without being selected. 9. Gil attributes the snubs partly to the new All-Star format requiring the international World team to have eight players, which he argues displaces three to four American spots that would otherwise go to legitimate All-Stars. 10. The panel debates the three-team format at length: Gil argues it further dilutes both American teams from 10-11 to 8 players each, preventing any single great American lineup from assembling. 11. Gil redirects the format debate to player effort: 'If you showed up to play hard for the fans, we wouldn't need to engineer the format at all,' prompting pushback from Nick Young and Brandon Jennings. 12. Josiah presents Nikola Jokic's All-Star Game statistics from the prior year: four points, five rebounds, and five assists across 16 combined minutes — from the player who had been NBA MVP four times. 13. Jamal Murray stated publicly before the current All-Star that he didn't play hard in prior games because there was 'no real reason to be an All-Star' when other players don't bring effort, despite having come close to All-Star selection four consecutive years. 14. Gil argues the Euros' dominance in regular season play — which he dates to approximately five years prior — has not translated into effort at the All-Star level, with Giannis Antetokounmpo's 2021 MVP being the exception. 15. The Paul George topic is introduced as the show's second segment: a 25-game suspension for violating the league's anti-drug policy, which Gil and the panel frame as potentially good news for the Philadelphia 76ers' playoff positioning. 16. James Harden's reported trade alignment with Cleveland — involving Darius Garland going to the Clippers — is set up as the lead topic, with the panel debating whether Harden would be a good fit in Cleveland. 17. Brandon Jennings notes the show has a golf tournament scheduled the following week, with Gil claiming to have reserved the entire golf course for the day. 18. The episode's tone is fast, confrontational, and frequently profane — panelists talk over each other, Gil becomes animated defending his dilution argument, and Josiah functions as a brake on the most heated exchanges. 19. The show is presented by Underdog Fantasy, with the hosts encouraging listeners to use code GILL for bonus entries, and notes audio versions are available on Apple and Spotify. 20. Best for fans of unfiltered NBA debate who want active player and ex-player takes on roster construction, All-Star politics, and league governance; not suited for listeners who prefer statistically rigorous or measured sports analysis.

As heard by us

Trade-deadline chaos and All-Star arguments keep the conversation moving.

Trade-deadline week gives the episode a clear pulse, but the sharper interest comes from how the panel widens an All-Star MVP debate into a question about effort, international stars, and whether the league's best players are helping or dragging on the product.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a loud NBA debate that swings from All-Star arguments to trade-deadline chatter?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Gil's Arena