Get Real with Caroline Hobby · Nashville Podcast Network

Getting Real with Kelly Chase: Why She Said “I Don’t” and Found Her Real Soulmate — Herself

October 13, 2025·1 hr 14 min·5 clips
Kelly Chase discovers her 'nice' behavior was actually high-functioning codependency and a form of control.
The interview takes her back to the point where things started to feel off. She talks through the path from the pods to the engagement, then the big reveal, Mexico, and the weeks they lived together in Atlanta. The wedding was only a few days away when the pressure finally got too hard to ignore. She says she kept reaching for practical reasons she felt unsettled: her mom was not there to try on the wedding dress with her, her best friends were missing from the bachelorette, and she did not have a proper bridal shower. The people around her pointed out that plenty of weddings happen without those exact moments, and that still did not explain what was going on. In the end, she says it plainly: she was not in love with him. Even after saying it out loud, she kept circling what had worked. He was a good man. She loved his family. Their parents got along. A lot of boxes were checked. That is part of why the decision felt so hard. Nothing about it looked obviously broken from the outside. The problem was quieter than that, and harder to name. The exchange stays with the gap between what looked fine and what felt true, and it lands less like spectacle than recognition. It is about what happens when a person cannot force a feeling just because everything around it seems to fit.

As heard by us

A candid breakup story that lands when honesty finally cuts through.

A near-wedding sits at the center of the conversation, but the real pull comes when she admits her head and heart are not lined up. The path runs through the pods, Mexico, and the weeks they spend living together in Atlanta before it lands on the plain statement that she is not…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When the boxes are checked but your heart still says no.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on