GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi · Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning

Response to 23 Questions - Part 155 - What is Hadith ( Hadees Kya Hai ) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

·40 min·2 clips

Razi and Ibn-e Kaseer explicitly read the verse as requiring shara and wazahat.

The session opens within the 23-objection series. From there, the conversation returns to the objection raised from Surah An-Nahl 16:44 and treats it as a question of wording, structure, and context rather than a slogan. They begin with the word. First they read the term on its own, then trace where it comes from, how the sentence is built, and what job it does inside the verse. That method stays steady. Ghamidi keeps saying the meaning has to be tested in stages, and the interviewer keeps the frame moving by asking which sense should be taken in this verse. The discussion turns on tabeen. One reading takes the term as explanation or clarification of the Quranic meaning, especially the parts meant to be opened up for the listener. Another reading is narrower. In that reading, the term is closer to narrating, conveying, or making known what has already been given directly to the Prophet and then reaches people through him. The wording matters here. The conversation pauses on why a different form was not used, then argues that the phrasing fits a movement from direct giving to mediated delivery. The speakers also return to the earlier point. They restate that the first part of the verse presents the zikr as something given directly to the Prophet, while the later wording points to its reaching other people through him. From that angle, tabeen can mean repeating and making known. The tafsir literature is reviewed. After surveying the scholars, the point is not treated as finally closed, but as a preference that still depends on which reading one judges stronger. The session keeps its confidence in method. The speakers close by saying that the Quran's meaning is complete and that mistakes usually live in human understanding, not in the text itself. The segment ends with criticism of Ghamidi's result and a promise to return to the discussion later.

As heard by us

A text-first discussion of how Quranic wording shapes the Hadith question.

The episode keeps to one question and works through it in a careful order: the word itself, the sentence structure, and then the verse's place in Surah An-Nahl.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a slow, text-first unpacking of Surah An-Nahl 16:44 and the wording around tabyeen, not a shortcut.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi