GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi · Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning

Response to 23 Questions - Part 146 - What is Hadith ( Hadees Kya Hai ) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

·24 min·1 clip

He argues that “Man Baddala Deenahu Faqtulu” must be read against “La Ikraha Fi Deen” and Quranic guidance.

1. GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi centers this episode on the second principle in Meezan: understanding Hadith through the Quran. 2. Javed Ahmed Ghamidi speaks as the main explainer, and the interviewer pushes him on standards, history, and whether Quran-first reading creates disagreement. 3. The episode asks how a listener should read Hadith reports when the Quran already provides the primary framework for religion and history. 4. Ghamidi’s first example is language: he says a person needs a “taste of the language of the Hadith” before rejecting anything on linguistic grounds. 5. He compares Hadith interpretation to understanding Ghalib, where the original text must be read before any sharh can be judged. 6. Ghamidi’s second example is the Quran as the standard, and he says Hadith should be read “in the light of the Quran.” 7. He argues that the Quran is “the Word of Allah” and the definitive source for the Prophet’s life wherever it mentions Badr, Uhud, Ahzab, Madinah, the hypocrites, or Ummahatul Momineen. 8. He says most Hadith material is derived from the essence, core, or shara of what the Quran already states. 9. He repeatedly contrasts the Quran as the “text” with Hadith as the explanation or expansion of that text. 10. He says the same method applies when a narration comments on a Quranic subject, because the text must be understood before the commentary can be weighed. 11. Ghamidi uses rajm, Kaab-e Ashraf, and the punishment narratives as examples where isolated readings produce mistakes. 12. He says the narrations on grave punishment and shafa'at become clearer when the Quran’s own statements about death, the hereafter, and divine judgment are placed first. 13. He discusses “Umirtu Anu Qatilan Naas” as a report about fighting, then asks what purpose fighting is supposed to serve. 14. He says “Man Baddala Deenahu Faqtulu” is often misunderstood unless it is read with “La Ikraha Fi Deen” and with the Quran’s guidance about belief and disbelief. 15. He points readers to his books Burhan and Maqamat for longer discussions of Kaab-e Ashraf, the insult of the Prophet, and related legal questions. 16. He also mentions Ilm-ul Nabi as a place where the narrations on grave punishment have been arranged and published. 17. The interviewer raises the issue of shan-e nuzool, and Ghamidi says the Quran itself gives the historical background needed to read surahs correctly. 18. The tone is explanatory and back-and-forth, with the interviewer repeatedly asking for clarification and Ghamidi responding with examples from Meezan, Tafseer-e Al-Bayan, and Tazabbur-e Quran. 19. People interested in Hadith methodology, Quranic interpretation, and Ghamidi’s writings on Meezan and Tafseer-e Al-Bayan would follow this closely. 20. Listeners wanting a general religious talk without technical Hadith and tafsir terminology may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi