GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi · Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning

Response to 23 Questions - Part 139 - What is Hadith ( Hadees Kya Hai ) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

·31 min·2 clips

Muawiya asks Zaid ibn Sabit to write hadith, and Zaid replies, “The Prophet ... instructed us that we will not write anything.”

1. GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, Qist No. 139, continues the series on “What is the Hadith?” with a focus on early Islamic transmission. 2. Ghamidi speaks as the primary analyst, and the host prompts him to explain how the Sahaba handled writing, narrating, and verifying hadith. 3. The episode asks what the three fundamental questions were from the Prophet’s time through the Khulafa-e-Rashidin, and why those answers mattered for later hadith history. 4. Ghamidi says two views developed on writing hadith: one treated the ban as permanent, and the other treated it as a temporary measure during Quranic preservation. 5. He argues that people who favored writing saw it as a natural requirement for memory, teaching family members, and passing knowledge to the next generation. 6. To illustrate this, he cites Abu Dawud 3644, where Muawiya asks Zaid ibn Sabit about a hadith and tells someone to write it down. 7. Zaid ibn Sabit responds that the Prophet ordered them not to write anything from his hadith, and Ghamidi says the written material was erased. 8. Ghamidi then says historical reports show more than 50 Sahaba wrote hadith, with some writing two reports, some four, some ten, and some larger collections. 9. He mentions Abdullah bin Amr bin As, Anas bin Malik, Ali ibn Abi Talib, and Amr bin Hazm as examples of companions linked to written material. 10. He also says some companions wrote during the Prophet’s lifetime while others wrote after the Prophet’s death, even though those writings did not survive in a stable compiled form. 11. On narrating hadith, Ghamidi says Abu Bakr and Umar were strict about keeping attention on the Quran and avoiding unnecessary report-sharing. 12. He then cites Musnad Ahmad 1413, where Zubair says he heard the warning, “Man kazaba alaiya muta‘ammidan fal yatabawwa maq‘adahu minan naar,” and therefore remained cautious. 13. He cites Sahih Bukhari 108, where Anas bin Malik says the same warning keeps him from narrating many hadith. 14. He cites Musnad al-Tialasi 80, where Usman ibn Affan says his restraint comes from hearing the Prophet warn against attributing to him what he did not say. 15. He adds Abu Qatada’s report in Musnad Ahmad 22538, where the Prophet warns people on the pulpit to say only truth when narrating from him. 16. He then cites Musnad Abi Yaala 1209, where Abu Said al-Khudri transmits the instruction to narrate without distortion and not to lie knowingly. 17. Ghamidi says these warnings produced a dominant Companion ethic of caution, while another group believed trustworthy knowledge should be conveyed when it was preserved accurately. 18. The tone is explanatory and source-driven, with Arabic phrasing, named collections, and repeated historical examples rather than debate-style confrontation. 19. Listeners interested in hadith history, Sahaba practice, and early Islamic transmission would get the most from this episode. 20. Listeners wanting short, light religious commentary without source citations would probably skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi