GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi · Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning

Response to 23 Questions - Part 138 - What is Hadith ( Hadees Kya Hai ) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

·26 min·1 clip

Abu Huraira says Umar would have struck him with his whip for narrating too freely.

1. GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi episode 138 discusses “What is Hadith ( Hadees Kya Hai )” through the early history of Hadith preservation. 2. Javed Ahmed Ghamidi leads the discussion as the main speaker and cites Urwa bin Zubair, al-Bayhaqi, Tadrib-ul-Rawi, Imam Zahabi, Abu Huraira, Karza bin Ka'b, and Syedna Umar. 3. The episode asks what the Hadith record is for, how the Sahaba treated it, and why writing and narration were handled cautiously. 4. Ghamidi explains that Syedna Umar considered the Prophet’s instruction against writing as a guidance tied to protecting the Quran, not an eternal ban. 5. He says Umar consulted the Sahaba about writing the Prophet’s sunan and then waited for a month before making a decision. 6. Umar’s final reasoning is quoted as a fear that people before them had written books and then pushed the Book of Allah aside. 7. The discussion presents this as a concern about attention shifting toward a compiled Hadith collection alongside the Quran. 8. Ghamidi then turns to narration and reads a report about Umar traveling with companions toward Iraq and telling them to keep the Quran separate. 9. Umar says the people in those villages would recite the Quran like bees humming, so the companions should not busy them with Hadith. 10. The phrase “Jarridul Quran” is used to mean that the Quran should be kept separate from everything else. 11. The same report also says “Aqilul Riwaya Ar Rasoolillah,” meaning narration from the Prophet should be kept to a minimum. 12. Karza bin Ka'b later reports that Umar stopped them from narrating Hadith in that manner. 13. Abu Huraira is then quoted as saying that if he narrated in Umar’s time the way he narrated later, Umar would have struck him with his whip. 14. Ghamidi uses that report to show how strict Umar was about public narration of Hadith. 15. Imam Zahabi is cited as concluding that Umar did not want people occupied with Hadith while forgetting the Quran. 16. Ghamidi says later Muhaddiseen treated Umar’s example as a model for verification when a single report reached them. 17. He connects that method to asking for witnesses and checking narrators rather than accepting a report automatically. 18. The tone is explanatory and citation-heavy, with long Arabic quotations and Urdu paraphrase. 19. People interested in early Hadith history and the Rashidun Caliphs would likely follow this discussion. 20. Listeners wanting a light, fast-paced episode may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi