GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi · Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning

Response to 23 Questions - Part 137 - What is Hadith ( Hadees Kya Hai ) - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

·33 min·2 clips

Syedna Abu Bakr collected about 500 hadiths, then burned the book because he feared misattribution.

1. GCIL Podcast’s Javed Ahmed Ghamidi episode 137 discusses “What is Hadith” as a historical record of the Prophet’s knowledge and practice. 2. Ghamidi is the central speaker, and the host asks him how the Khulafa-e Rashideen treated hadith after the Prophet’s death. 3. The episode asks what Abu Bakr did with writing, verbal narration, and verification when the Sahaba inherited the Prophet’s reports. 4. Ghamidi says the first question was whether the Prophet’s ban on writing was permanent or tied to specific circumstances. 5. He says the second question was whether the Prophet’s permission to narrate verbally remained valid after his death. 6. He says the third question was how to investigate reports when a religious issue arises and people disagree. 7. Ghamidi identifies Abu Bakr as the first and most important figure after the Prophet in both political and knowledge matters. 8. He quotes Umar’s high оценation of Abu Bakr’s knowledge, taqwa, relationship with the Prophet, and service to the deen. 9. He says Abu Bakr’s practice shows that the writing ban was not understood as an eternal command. 10. He describes Abu Bakr organizing a collection of about 500 narrations and giving it to Ayesha. 11. Ghamidi says Abu Bakr later burned that collection because he feared attributing a mistake to the Prophet. 12. He emphasizes Abu Bakr’s concern that he might die while carrying narrations that were heard, misunderstood, or copied inaccurately. 13. Ghamidi says Abu Bakr gathered people after the Prophet’s death and told them not to narrate anything from the Prophet in a general way. 14. He quotes Abu Bakr’s instruction that people should refer to “Baynana wa baynakum Kitabullah.” 15. He says Abu Bakr treated the Quran as the decisive source for halal and haram. 16. He explains that Abu Bakr’s concern was with contradiction and uncertainty in verbal reporting, not with denying the Prophet’s authority. 17. Ghamidi then narrates the grandmother inheritance case as a test of how a hadith could be accepted through testimony. 18. He says Abu Bakr asked for corroboration, al-Mughira narrated the report, and Muhammad ibn Maslama testified before Abu Bakr implemented the ruling. 19. The tone is explanatory and evidence-driven, with long-form argumentation and repeated reference to specific reports from Tazkirat-ul-Huffaz. 20. Listeners interested in hadith methodology and early caliphal practice will get the most from it, while listeners wanting light discussion or short anecdotes may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from GCIL PODCAST - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi